Jump to content

The arrogance to think you know gods will.


Recommended Posts

This piece of crap midwife (term only used because the paper did) To let a child die because she thinks she knows what god wants? Can she prove that's what god wanted and not what she wanted? it's only her faith talking god has nothing to do with it. So I guess if she took the child to the hospital and he died then she can claim it but since she did nothing How can she claim it? I think this is one of my biggest problems with religion in that people think they know what god wants and act on it. But no one can agree on what god wants so how can it be?

To do nothing and claim it is gods will Shames god and yourself.

Church midwife says premature baby's death was 'God's will'

Steve Mayes, The Oregonian

Published: Sep 23, 2011 7:38 PM

Photo 1 of 1

A church midwife who attended the home birth of David Hickman, who was born two months early and lived only nine hours, said she does not believe the premature baby should have been taken to the hospital.

In unusually candid testimony, Lavona Keith said "it wasn't God's will for David to live."

Keith testified for the defense Friday at the trial of Dale and Shannon Hickman. The Oregon City couple are accused of second-degree manslaughter for failing to seek medical care for David, who died in 2009.

The medical examiner determined the infant died from underdeveloped lungs and staph pneumonia. Medical experts previously called by the prosecution disputed whether a staph infection played a role in the baby's death, but a second defense witness, Dr. Stanley Berry disagreed. He said David died of a staph-related blood infection that was not obvious to those who attended the home birth.

The Hickmans and Keith are members of the Followers of Christ, an Oregon City church that preaches faith healing and rejects doctors and medical care.

Previous coverage

» The Hickman case

» The Followers of Christ

Keith, who is Shannon Hickman's aunt and one of three church midwives who attended the birth, said David "pinked right up and was vibrant and healthy." She said she had no concerns about the baby's well-being when she left him two or three hours after the birth.

Under questioning by prosecutor John Wentworth, Keith said it is for God to decide whether a baby lives or dies.

"Is there anything a doctor can do to change that?" Wentworth asked.

"I don't think so," Keith said.

The central theme of the prosecution's case is that the Hickmans' actions -- before and after David's birth -- led to his death, including their decision not to seek prenatal care and failure to call 9-1-1 when the child's condition deteriorated and he stopped breathing.

Instead the Hickmans relied on church midwives.

"What would you do if a baby was struggling to breathe?" Wentworth asked.

"I would anoint" the child with oil but would not call a doctor, Keith said. "I believe in trusting in God."

What would God do, Wentworth asked.

"He would heal my baby," Keith said.

"What lesson was learned from David's death?" Wentworth asked.

"I don't know," Keith replied.

Berry said medical intervention wouldn't have mattered. David died in a matter of minutes once the blood infection struck, and nothing could have been done to save the child. The baby "was doing fine until (he) fell off a cliff," said Berry, an obstetrician and fetal medicine specialist at William Beaumont Hospital in Detroit.

Prosecutors said Berry's conclusions are not supported by laboratory tests and are more theory than science.

The state medical examiner who performed an autopsy found large concentrations of bacteria and suspected Group B streptococcus, which causes blood and lung infections that can quickly kill. Attempts to culture the bacteria and specifically identify the strain were unsuccessful.

Based on David's initial healthy appearance then rapid decline, Berry said Group B strep was the obvious culprit.

-- Steve Mayes

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Isn't Group B strep an infection that obgyns test pregnant mothers for BEFORE they give birth? I'm pretty sure I remember being tested for the infection before I gave birth so that if I had the infection it could be treated so that I didn't pass it to my baby during delivery.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Isn't Group B strep an infection that obgyns test pregnant mothers for BEFORE they give birth? I'm pretty sure I remember being tested for the infection before I gave birth so that if I had the infection it could be treated so that I didn't pass it to my baby during delivery.

would it mater since they would never go to a doctor? because of course they are doing gods will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Trending Content

  • Recent Status Updates

    • 47of74


      Finally found the real settings that make Microsoft's software behave as it does....

      · 0 replies
    • bea


      Planning on scheduling my ankle surgery around Trump's Georgia trial - if I'm forced to be off my feet, I might as well be entertained.
      · 0 replies
    • 47of74


      And yes, the Church actually has a blessing for beer.
      · 0 replies
    • 47of74


      If anyone is still wondering about my preferred method of dealing with Branch Trumpvidians...
      "I will crucify the Masters. I will set their fleets afire, kill every last one of their soldiers, and return their cities to the dirt." - Daenerys Targaryen
      · 0 replies
    • quiversR4hunting


      Mug shot day! I've popped my popcorn and ready to go watch MSNBC. 
      I can't believe some people still believe the orange lying, criminal pos! 
      · 0 replies
    • quiversR4hunting


      Stupid loneliness!
      Kid 1 went back to college (yeah! But sad foe me, she stayed with me all summer. It was nice to start a new phase in our mother/daughter relationship)
      Zero prospects on dates. (Not that I have tried online dating, scared of that but I have reached put to a new group at church, etc.
      I asked a friend to go to dinner the other night so I wasn't eating alone, again. The friend had plans, all my friends always have plans. I see stuff on social media, I'm never invited. I'm single, I'm the 3rd or 5th wheel.
      My one parent friend at kid 2's fall sport won't be there because their daughter made varsity (Yeah for her!!! Seriously happy for her. Sad for me for another sport I basically sit alone, did that majority of spring and summer sporting events.)
      And now I'm crying as my mom told me 2 different funny stores that former teachers remembered about my twin. Both stories were about how they got a crack out of my twin's antics (my parents went to a funeral today and saw former colleagues). Teachers remember me (after all I was a twin and teachers' kid) but none would have memorable stories of me. 
      I feel invisible. 
      Don't worry, this will pass,  it always does. I just need a pity party for a few days. I'm not in anyway going to harm myself. As lonely as I am, I have a very full life I (usually) love. I just needed to vent and cry for a moment. 
      If you are still reading this, thanks Fjer. 😊 
      · 3 replies
    • lawlifelgbt


      Absolutely awful about the fires on Maui. In 2019, I stayed in Lahaina. I liked to sit on the sea wall, which is the only structure left now, and watch the water. People are receiving help, but many had to leave pets. Please donate to the Maui Humane Society, which is leading efforts to find, treat, and reunite pets.
      · 2 replies
    • BlackberryGirl


      Hap carpal tunnl surgery Monday. Already feel a difference. Yay.
      · 5 replies
    • louisa05


      Nebraska’s new football coach, who is involved in an organization called Man Up Ministries, labels certain players “Alphas” and sometimes “extreme Alphas” and the local paper has a nice piece on why people objecting to the term “alpha male” are wrong and it has a “nice ring”. 🤮🤮🤮🤮
      · 12 replies
    • closetcagebaby


      sometimes i wish you could… rent a mom? or just an experienced woman older than me for advice! just venting as i really wish my mom was someone i could be on speaking terms with, but alas. 
      · 1 reply
  • Recent Blog Entries

  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.