Jump to content
  • Sky
  • Blueberry
  • Slate
  • Blackcurrant
  • Watermelon
  • Strawberry
  • Orange
  • Banana
  • Apple
  • Emerald
  • Chocolate
  • Charcoal
Sign in to follow this  
Soldier of the One

Patriarchy/Androcentrism - Definitions

Recommended Posts

Soldier of the One

Buzzard kindly requested me to start this thread with a definition of terms. Now, I don't know if I am fully equipped to provide those definitions so I welcome peer review!

Androcentrism and Patriarchy are terms that are used a lot in FJ discourse when it comes to discussing fundamentalist thought. There are many nuances and shades to these definitions including contextual ones: these words may mean something different in general, secular parlance than they do in religious, fundamentalist parlance.

Of course, I could go to Webster's but I won't do that - unless someone really wants me to. I am happy to paste it in here at a later point.

I'd define androcentrism as a cultural phenomenon that places men and men's interests at the center of the social experience. A man (or a woman) can be an androcentrist when they deem men more important, valuable or essential to the human experience - be it through leadership, sexuality or any other cultural meme.

For instance, VF is androcentric in the sense that it places the male experience at the center of both its ministry and its theology. It is the male experience that matters most - women are there ultimately not for their intrinsic worth but to help facilitate the male experience. The concept of 'helpmeet' engenders this. Doug Phillips takes this androcentrism to even higher levels through the programming of his ministry - Father and Son retreats, an emphasis on homosocial relationships etc. This even has theological ramifications through androcentric theology: in which the 'maleness' of Deity is affirmed and only males are deemed suitable as spiritual leaders.

I'd define patriarchy in a number of ways:

1) General patriarchy (also known in general society): the rule of men over women. This is, of course, a terse and limited statement as experience teaches us that not all men rule over all women. There always have been noted exceptions to the rule. (ie. female Biblical prophets, Queen Elizabeth I, Hillary Clinton, etc). But often the exceptions affirm the rule because they are so rare and often rarified in the perception of general society.

A patriarchal society will - to a more or lesser degree - consider women subordinate to men and consider them to inhabit a personhood-chattel continuum. In milder cases, a woman is seen mostly as a person and only as chattel sometimes (i.e. Western marriage customs, Jewish Orthodox marriage right of 'purchasing' the bride with the ring) and this position of chattel may be entirely symbolic (though still powerful) as opposed to legal. (Women in most Western societies have equal rights but still experience patriarchy). In more extreme cases, a woman is seen mostly as chattel with only certain undertones of personhood (i.e. Biblical patriarchy where women are seen as spiritually equal to men but not ontologically or socially). Patriarchal customs can include such things as 'wifely submission' and 'transfer of authority' popular in certain fundie circles. In all cases of patriarchy, women's agency does not have parity with men's and women's agency is limited or diminished.

2) Biblical Patriarchy: this refers to a specific ideology popular in Quiverfull, Dominionist and fundamentalist cultures. Biblical patriarchy refers to an attempt to restore (or reinvent) the patriarchal structures of Bible times, especially Old Testament times. These perceptions may or may not line up with actual evidence provided by Biblical scholarship on what Israelite or early Christian society looks like but is only based on a (narrow!) exegesis of the Biblical text through a literalist and fundamentalist lens.

Tenets of Biblical Patriarchy include the idea that women are always under male authority: be it father or husband (and in some extreme cases, male sibling) and that a 'transfer of authority' takes place from the father to the husband when the woman weds. But Biblical Patriarchy up to a lesser degree also circumscribes the lives of young, unmarried men who live under the authority of their fathers until they wed and establish their own household. In that sense, it can be a control-grid that affects both sexes and that locks unmarried children into expectations of obedience.

Biblical Patriarchy also has theological ramifications: it teaches a particular doctrine of Trinity (see Vision Forum Ministries) in which the Triune Godhead is not in equal relationship with Itself (Father, Son, Holy Spirit - often conceived of as female in normative Christian thought) but rather where the Son (both in the flesh as Jesus of Nazareth and in the spirit) is seen as being in continual obedient submission to the Father. This then, becomes a model for both unmarried sons, unmarried daughters and married wives.

Christian Patriarchs differ in opinion on how far their patriarchy extends. More moderate ones only preach female submission within the context of marriage. More extremist Patriarchs preach submission of all women to the three spheres of Family, Church and Government.


Hope this helps!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Soldier of the One

Just adding what I wrote in the 'What is Vision Forum/Patriarchy' thread on Trinity because it is relevant to this discussion:

Not only is VF socially 'androcentric' but also theologically. And their theology filters into everything else. They believe that every part of the Christian Godhead (i.e. the Trinity) is masculine. Most mainstream Christian theologians (correct me if I am wrong, Christians!) would at least consider the Holy Spirit neutral at best or even explicitly feminine. They also have an odd theological belief that the Son is in continual submission to the Father, while other Christian theologians teach that the Son was in submission to the Father only when in the flesh and that the Trinity is composed of three equal aspects of God.

This might seem like theological nitpicking but it's relevant because it totally filters down into their perception and reconstruction of the patriarchal family: hence, by extension, the Father has complete authority over his children and wife, rather than being in partnership with the wife (as the Holy Spirit could be seen as being in partnership with the Father in mainstream Christian theology). They write on their Ministries website that the father-son relationship is paralleled in the Godhead, in a near mystical fashion. This only informs their 'idolatrous' worship of the family and the father's role therein.

Unsurprisingly, VF Ministries organizes activities for fathers and sons (to affirm this metaphysical model), for fathers and daughters (to instill submissive virtues in the young women and to bolster the authority of the father), for mothers and daughters (so that daughters learn to emulate their virtuous mothers and accept 'transfer of authority') but never mothers and sons. Do mothers and sons need no particular bonding? Apparently, for VF, no. My theory is that women have no intrinsic value according to VF theology and that in their view, the mother-son relationship is fraught with tension because of issues of authority: on the one hand, the mother has authority over her (young) son but on the other hand, this is mitigated by the fact that any male has inherent authority over any female under patriarchy. So that relationship is not fostered.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Most mainstream Christian theologians (correct me if I am wrong, Christians!) would at least consider the Holy Spirit neutral at best or even explicitly feminine.

I have never heard the Holy Spirit referred to as anything other than "He". Certainly not as feminine, for sure. Though there may be liberal denominations that do.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Latest Mood Updates

    • JoyfulSel
      JoyfulSel is now feeling Giddy
    • tabitha2
      tabitha2 is now feeling Depressed
    • tiachutis
      tiachutis is now feeling Meh
    • LearningtoFly
      LearningtoFly is now feeling Nervous
    • precious blessing
      precious blessing is now feeling Wine time!
  • Recent Status Updates

    • louisa05


      Sick rabbit. Our vet is out of town. Can't find a vet that treats rabbits to see him. 😓
      · 0 replies
    • PumaLover


      Mr. Puma just surprised me with a much newer, much faster laptop! Now I can read more FJ! Yay! #besthubbyever LOL.
      · 0 replies
    • nst


      I start my new part time job today in a non profit company. 
      Not nervous because it's part time. 
      I am so glad I am no longer with the professor. 
      I just want to be a ray of light and service 
      · 1 reply
    • LittleOwl


      Apparently I am trying Bouldering on Saturday.  With the upper body strength of a flower, this can only end well... right? 
      · 4 replies
    • OyHiOh


      Went to a writer's group meeting yesterday.  First time I've gone to this group's meetings.  Different from other groups I've participated in - this one was a series of prompts and exercises.  I was in a bit of a mood going in - Father's Day weekend for a recent widow is no laugh matter; several social/annoying things happened at Shabbat service in the morning, and one of our service leaders made a "somebody really should" statement of the writing variety and once I hear someone say "someone really should" I usually can't unsee the idea until I've had a try at it.  We did a word association map for one exercise, then wrote something based on part or all of the word map.  I picked a section of the map that had some references to knives and fancy dress balls to write from.  I'm pretty proud of what I wrote in 15 minutes but it's pretty clear that I was in a "mood."
      The night of the long knives came and went as a plague on the first born of the land.  Men perfectly healthy went to bed only to be jerked from sleep with knives against their throats.  Here were the leaders of men, thrust against walls at the point of a stiletto, there the young men only following their orders, and over there again the family men who didn't exactly plan to pursue this path but perfectly content where they'd found themselves.  At the end of a blade, deep in the depression years, taking their payslips home at the end of the week feeling they'd done a good job, and a little extra for mother in the kitchen. The years of children, church, and kitchen. The good women. Most of them not owning a fancy pair of shoes or a party dress, for who had time?  The children needed their mothers at home, the men away at work.
      The children of course, were not silent.  Soldiers burst into their homes, dragged their fathers out of bed.  Mothers clutching their husbands, children wailing for their papas. The ones who understood left quietly, reassuring the children on their way out - it's a special exercise, I couldn't know about it beforehand, otherwise I would have told you.  Hush child, I'll be home in a few days. They knew they'd be lucky to make it to the end of the block, of course, but let the children hope for a little bit longer, before all hope fell away and their eyes opened to the hatred their own fathers had taken part in.
      Others didn't understand, resisted and fought against the soldiers who came into their homes.  They'd believed in the banners and flags, they'd stood and cheered, they'd enjoyed seeing fear cross the faces of those who understood.  Now they themselves fought back in fear. Fear of losing their lives for who could possibly know what comes next? Wagner wrote of Valhalla, their wives faithfully attended church; surely there was something to greet them when the heart stopped quivering, trying to pump blood flowing onto floors, and truck beds, and sidewalks.  
      · 0 replies
    • Dreadcrumbs


      I'm hooked on Duolingo. It's more helpful than I initially thought.
      · 0 replies
    • mollysmom


      Almost lost my little dog Molly today  Thankfully she seems to be ok but the next 24 hours are crucial. My ex husband came home to find her blanket wrapped around her neck real tight and she was just laying on the floor. He got her untangled and the blanket had blood on it and she had pooped and peed (probably so scared while it was happening) She started coughing up blood and her one eye is all bulged out and bloody. He called me and I told him to get her to the nearest emergency vet and I would meet him there. They said she's really lucky to be alive. They said to keep a close eye on her breathing the next 24 hours but after that if she's ok she should be fine. They sent her home with eyedrops and an anti-inflammatory medicine for her little neck. I'm so happy that she is ok but man, my heart is broken just thinking about how terrified my poor little baby was! I really really hope dogs have short memories so she doesn't remember this but even thinking about how she was most likely struggling just breaks my heart. I know she's "just" a dog so this is probably silly to alot of people, I totally get that, but she is my baby. I never had children. Molly is my baby. Everytime I think about how she was probably feeling I just cry. But I'm so glad she's alive.
      · 9 replies
    • AliceInFundyland


      Ch. 3 Sneak Attack
      While in bed, two ants appear on my arm. Instead of approaching this logically, I spray the ant spray straight behind my nightstand.
      Immediately. Don't do that.
      · 3 replies
    • melon

      melon  »  clueliss

      clueliss,I love your profile pic.
      I have 3 torties.I have 3 tabbies and 1 black or tuxedo cat.
      · 0 replies
    • HerNameIsBuffy


      Got up at 6:30 and made kids’ breakfast before they went to work.  Cleaned up and laid back down for a second to plan what I was going to do this morning aaaaannnnndddd...
      Just woke up a little after noon.  
      Just me and the fur kiddos and I’m trying really hard not to follow sleeping in with a long nap.
      · 3 replies
  • Recent Blog Entries

  • Popular Tags