Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    84,567

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory: Chapter 11


Maggie Mae

2,366 views

Chapter 11: The Miracle

Charlie goes to the candy store and buys a Wonka Whipple-Scrumptious Fudgemallow Delight. Maggie Mae tears open a Russell Stover Mini Egg, with Fudge Brownie filling. I think it's pretty similar. 50% off! I put the rest of the bag in the jar with the old Halloween candy, the christmas/Hanukkah candy, and the Valentine's day candy. There is probably candy in there from two Halloweens ago. I know there are New Years Eve Noisemakers from three years ago, also in the same jar. I know this because one was used last night. 

Oh, so in the book, Charlie buys this candy bar from a "fat and well-fed" man. He is described in great detail about how he is fat and his neck bulges out over his shirt collar. This shopkeeper watches as Charlie shoves the candy bar into Charlie's mouth like he was starving. I guess Charlie is starving, though, so it's OK. 

The man tells Charlie to slow down and make sure to chew, to avoid the "gut-ache." 

Charlie decides to buy a second candy bar and bring 80 cents back to his mother. One dollar in 1964 is equivalent to 7.65 today, so I guess it might buy a meal. I've lived in a high cost-of-living area for so long that I don't actually know what 7.65 would buy at a grocery store. Maybe ingredients for a stir-fry? For 4. Or a LOT of almost expiring bananas. 

The second candy bar - same type as the last - has a Golden Ticket! We all knew he would get one, and now it's happened! 

The shopkeeper does not assault Charlie and steal it, he does however, draw more attention that I would be comfortable with to the situation. Did you know the shopkeeper was fat? If you had forgotten, it's helpfully pointed out again. 

A "large boy" is angry because he's been eating 20 chocolate bars a day trying to win this ticket. A girl laughs and says that Charlie will need the free chocolate, as he is a "skinny little shrimp." (What is up with people and making fun of fat and skinny people? Why can't we just not do that?) 

People offer to buy the Golden Ticket from Charlie. Finally the "fat shopkeeper" helps him out of the store, tells him to run home, and don't let anyone have it.  The "fat shopkeeper" mentions that he thinks Charlie needs a break like this. 

So the "fat shopkeeper" isn't a villain, really, although the other adults are. So maybe it's not really fat shaming? It still seemed jarring to read about this man's weight so many times in such a short chapter. The other adults, though, are terrible. $50 and a bicycle? How awful to try and cheat a kid like that! Even $500 is still not even close to what the ticket is worth! How much do you think Veruca's dad spent on chocolate to try and get one ticket? I'm kind of surprised that no one else sold a ticket. If I had gotten one, I'd sell it for sure! A lifetime supply of candy, plus an exclusive look inside the chocolate factory is worth a lot more than $500. If I didn't sell it, I'd for sure bring a secret spy pen camera and take pictures and sell those. Or write a book about what I saw and sell that. And the candy. I don't think I eat that much candy, so I'd be donating that to soup kitchens or something. Or maybe just leave it at the end of a race, when people will eat just about anything. 

wpid-photo-20140327210259.jpg

Charlie.jpg

8c22fc1fba5e016cc27a9c5856775f9c.jpg

 

  • Upvote 4

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

blessalessi

Posted

Wasn't it considered a good, healthy thing, and a sign of wealth, to be "plump" in the early sixties?  

When did Twiggy become famous? (Not that she would have influenced the average industrial town inhabitants....)

In UK old money, Charlie had found a half crown, worth 2 shillings and sixpence (or 5 Whipple-Scrumptious Fudgemallow Delights).  Google tells me that a loaf of bread cost between 9d and 1 shilling. Vegetables could be bought by the penny according to this article.  

I don't think a fresh stir-fry would quite have been on the menu, but a more affluent family than Charlie's might have been tempted to splurge on a freeze-dried box of Vesta Chow Mein. If you have ever masticated on one of these delights, you will know that the idea of a three-course meal in chewibg gum form is really not all that far-fetched!  :P

 

11b5993bffd9f678a9bdaef30c35e4c1.jpg

  • Upvote 4
Link to comment
OnceUponATime

Posted

Quote

"In writing for children," as Dahl once put it, "you have to exaggerate a million times in order to ram the point home." Charlie's poverty is not "phoney", it is melodramatic. Symbolism, not realism, becomes the order of the day.

I think that is [at least partly] the reason why the the fat shopkeeper is a fat guy,  (quote from here)

  • Upvote 4
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.