Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    85,913

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

Game of Thrones: Bran I


Maggie Mae

1,507 views

This chapter is in the POV of Bran Stark. I still haven't decided on a good schedule, and I'm not sure how useful the character lists are, but I figure as I go along I'll figure out a style and format. Thanks for bearing with my attempt at recaping a book! 

Characters met in this chapter

  • Bran - a boy of seven
  • Robb - Fair skin, red-brown hair, blue eyes. (like the Tullys)
  • Gared - earless, dressed in the black of the Night's Watch. A deserter. 
  • Jon Snow - Bran's bastard brother. Dark grey eyes. Same age as Robb
  • Lord Eddard Stark - 35 years old, beard shot with white, long brown hair. Grey eyes. 
  • Theon Greyjoy - Lord Stark's Ward. 19. Finds everything amusing. 
  • Jory Cassel - captain of the Stark Household 
  • Hullen - Master of Horse
  • Harwin - Hullen's son
  • Desmond

 

Characters mentioned but not seen

  • Mance Rayder - "King-beyond-the-Wall"
  • Old Nan
  • Robert of the King Baratheon, the First of his Name, King of the Andals and they Rhoynar and the First Men, Lord of the Seven Kingdoms and Protector of the Realm. 
  • The Tullys of Riverrun
  • Targaryen kings before Robert
  • Ser Rodrik
  • Rickon (The youngest Stark)

Short Version

Bran rides his pony with the male members of his family. Eddard Stark carries out the king's justice, beheading a man I believe is Gared. (The descriptions match perfectly.) Theon is a jerk.  On the ride back to the Castle, Robb finds some direwolves. 

 

Longer version

Twenty men ride with Lord Eddard Stark to a small holdfast in the hills. Bran, a seven-year-old boy, accompanies his father, Lord Eddard Stark and company. When they arrive, they see a man who matches the description of Gared from the previous chapter. He is executed using a Valyrian steel spell forged sword called Ice. Theon laughs and kicks Gared's head away when it rolls toward him. Robb and Jon discuss whether the deserter was brave. Jon Snow believes that the man was afraid, not brave.  Bran and Lord Stark have a conversation about fear and bravery, which leads into why Lord Stark carries out his executions while King Robert has a headsman. They come across a dead direwolf half covered in snow with five pups. Lord Stark is going to have them executed when Jon steps in and points out that the direwolf is the symbol of House Stark and Lord Stark has 5 trueborn sons and daughters. As they leave, they find another direwolf puppy, an albino, far from the pack. Jon Snow claims it as his own.

 

Thoughts

SO MANY GOOD QUOTES. 

Theon is such a dick. I feel bad for him, of course, but he is really unsympathetic here. I know he's a ward, which means that he's technically a hostage. Which makes his position and story particularly sucky, but man, his personality is uncool. Also, he has to carry that giant sword around. The sword that could one day behead him if Lord Greyjoy breaks the terms of peace. 

Ned Stark does not believe in signs. Until he sort of does when Jon steps in, saving the lives of the direwolves. Speaking of direwolves, that's some symbolism. The Stag's (symbol of House Baratheon) antler broke off into a grey direwolf that lay on white snow. Ned Stark is the one to pull the foot of antler out of the throat of the wolf. Jory says that perhaps the wolf was already dead. Ned says "better a swift death than one from cold and starvation." Considering what is coming, I can't imagine that these lines, in particular, don't have multiple meanings. 

There is also some language in the beginning where Old Nan tells stories of the Others breeding with men and creating horrible half-human children. Children of the Forest, maybe? No, that can't be. The First Men drove the Children Out. Or was that the Andals? I don't remember. 

I had forgotten about the part where Bran talks about how his father would sit in front of the fire and talk about the age heroes and children of the forest. It's nice to think about how nice life in Winterfell really was. Before King Robert came along and ruined it. 

 Jon Snow is the only one to hear Ghost. Jon Snow thinks he might have crawled away, but Ned wonders if he wasn't driven away. Much like what is going to happen to Jon in just a few chapters. He is white, instead of grey. And his eyes are open. Earlier Jon is described and his eyes are dark grey, but "little they did not see." 

  • Upvote 1

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

This is a pretty good recap, it's hard to cut down all those words into a fairly brief recap of events. I haven't re-read AGOT in a while (been focused on ADWD) but this is kind of inspiring me to do so.

It's so sad looking back on how good the Starks had it at Winterfell. I miss Ned. Poor noble, stupid man.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

This is a pretty good recap, it's hard to cut down all those words into a fairly brief recap of events. I haven't re-read AGOT in a while (been focused on ADWD) but this is kind of inspiring me to do so.

It's so sad looking back on how good the Starks had it at Winterfell. I miss Ned. Poor noble, stupid man.

It's also difficult because he really packs so much into every sentence. Some of it is just really great descriptions. It's amazing to me how this chapter was able to showcase the personalities of Jon, Robb, Theon, and Ned so well. And the way he used Bran - who was 7 and wouldn't remember/pay close attention to all the talking before the execution - was smart because the reader won't get to hear what Gared has to say. And it was obvious that the men had seen the stag in the direwolf for what it was, but Bran didn't really "get" it. Nor would the reader at that point. 

The Starks had it the best, IMO. Ned was a noble and responsible fair leader. They had the best castle (personal opinion, of course) and other than Dorne, it seems like one of the better places for women. 

Link to comment

The First Men were the, well first (hu)mens, to come from ??? to Westeros. They had a big ol' native vs. foreigner civil war, but when the Others came (The Long Night), they banded together and drove them back to the true North. The Wall goes up because magic and other cool shit. The Children and the First Men lived coexisted peacfully for the next centuries. Then the Andals show up with the Faith of the Seven (Christianity) and ruin all the magic and the Children go so deep into hiding that all their wisdom is lost expect the Old Gods for the Northerners, who have the purest blood of the First Men. 

Any questions? No? Good! Because that shows how deep fandoms get for me. I need to relearn my no shame stance on life. 

But, seriously, Maggie Mae, I'm more than willing to help out if you need cross references. I've read all the lore, so if you need help, I'm your girl! 

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

On 11/23/2015 at 9:23 PM, TacoCat said:

The First Men were the, well first (hu)mens, to come from ??? to Westeros. They had a big ol' native vs. foreigner civil war, but when the Others came (The Long Night), they banded together and drove them back to the true North. The Wall goes up because magic and other cool shit. The Children and the First Men lived coexisted peacfully for the next centuries. Then the Andals show up with the Faith of the Seven (Christianity) and ruin all the magic and the Children go so deep into hiding that all their wisdom is lost expect the Old Gods for the Northerners, who have the purest blood of the First Men. 

Any questions? No? Good! Because that shows how deep fandoms get for me. I need to relearn my no shame stance on life. 

But, seriously, Maggie Mae, I'm more than willing to help out if you need cross references. I've read all the lore, so if you need help, I'm your girl! 

I'm sorry I just saw this, almost two months later. Thanks for the history lesson! I'll keep you in mind next time :)

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

It's quite alright! I overly involved in a few fandoms and ASoIaF is one of my favorites. I'm an endless supply of random facts and trivia. I can't remember what I ate for breakfast, but you can bet your ass I can tell you the entire history of some random house. The ASoIaF wiki is a great source to check any details that may be hazy. The people who run the wiki know more about Planetos than GRRM.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • Xan

      Posted

      I always find these Trump fantasy worlds very bizarre.  He's never in a nice suit meeting a world leader or even in a fireman's suit saving a child from a burning building.  It's always some fake macho outfit and, in this case, driving a car with a Confederate flag on it.  Their heroes don't seem that heroic.

    • JDuggs

      Posted

      On 12/22/2023 at 11:51 PM, JDuggs said:

      It looks like Micah is in a relationship, or very good friends, with this Florida realtor Veronica Peters. I’ve seen photos of them together on Micah’s IG, but I always thought she kind of looked too old for him. Maybe not.

      This was on Moriah’s IG:

        Hide contents

      image.thumb.jpeg.e5583f82734714ccb023fc889e4f0f90.jpeg

      And this was on Veronica’s personal IG and professional IG:

        Hide contents

      image.thumb.jpeg.e637a588be2f14fc379935962e743f47.jpeg

        Hide contentsimage.thumb.png.bfaa9a4a2ac77388067acef5c5afb81c.png

       

      Quoting myself from six months ago. I think this really is Micah’s girlfriend. She doesn’t seem quite as public about their relationship as she did back then.

      This photo of Veronica didn’t get copied over from my old post.

      Spoiler

      image.thumb.jpeg.0ae44da117d43f1db49868c42924ea03.jpeg

       

      • Upvote 1
    • JermajestyDuggar

      Posted

      There was a post on social media talking about this recent interview with Ballerina Farm and asking what people think about some of the things in it. So many commenters were like, “it’s her business! It’s not your life so why do you care?” This is the type of thing that bugs me to no end. Ballerina Farm posts their lives willingly! They post their children’s lives! Of course people will speculate and care! If they didn’t put their lives all over social media none of us would know anything about them. 

      • Upvote 1
    • LongTimeLurkerOG

      Posted

      On 7/25/2024 at 6:47 PM, LilMissMetaphor said:

      Just FYI in case someone missed it the first time round, this is what Art wrote on Reddit a year ago addressing some of the concerns that were brought up.  It's very telling if you read between some of the lines.

      "I don’t lie or make fraudulent claims to get money. That’s what a grifter is. I’ve closed all previous fundraisers and not all of them were successfully funded – for instance my legal name change and wedding fund did not get funded, so I still haven’t had a chance to do those things.

      I’m unable to work for a variety of medically supported reasons. It’s not okay to ask disabled people for proof of their disability simply because it’s medical information. To entertain the question is to concede that it’s okay to go ask other disabled people for their private medical history. It’s a common misconception that people pretend to be disabled for benefits or monetary gain, but it’s rare and doesn’t really make sense to do because benefits and fundraising add up to so little.

      I have been going to Seattle to look at possible places to live because it’s literally unavoidable, and I’ve been in severe pain because of it. That doesn’t mean I could do manual labor on a consistent basis. I don’t even drive, so I’ve had to cover gas and ask friends for help with rides.

      Have you ever tried working at a call center? I have. They’re severely strict and demanding, and incredibly demoralizing without paying much. They’re not an accessible alternative for people who can’t do more demanding manual labor. “Get a job like the rest of us” is ableist and is a fundamental misunderstanding of how accessible jobs are. It’s no better than yelling it at someone panhandling on the street. The supposedly “easy” or “low-skill” jobs are still difficult to do.

      I do use what resources I can, but it’s a total myth that there’s a robust social welfare system anywhere in the United States. If there was, we wouldn’t have so many hundreds of thousands of homeless people here, with millions more just a few missed paychecks away from joining them.

      The toxic mold was confirmed. My partner is literally terminally ill from it. If you read the actual updates, the name of the illness and the research surrounding it have been detailed. We have a letter from the pulmonologist that we sent to the landlord explaining that the environment my partner was in was causing the illness. Again, you’re demanding medical proof that you have no reason to ask about. Some things can’t just be washed out.

      I am as clear as I can possibly be about specific needs so that people know what they’re helping to support. I have said again and again that people shouldn’t give unless they can spare it and want to help. I even said that in the post linked to in this comment thread. My patreon is explicitly to support my writing.

      So why am I still fundraising and making money off telling my story? Because I literally have no other real options. I’ve been formally diagnosed with PTSD, it’s not “alleged trauma.” If it was working all that well, I wouldn’t have to keep detailing my needs.

      The real grifters in our society are billionaires, not poor disabled people. You sound like you just hate us for trying to exist."

      I remember reading this before. Well, they can take all their reasons and Stop. Grifting. Plenty of people with disabilities work and /or receive assistance (as I mentioned previously, my exPOS, who has disabilities so I'm familiar with a number of options and money). Some family, have / had disabilities. I've been an advocate for services and staff training (and provided training) for Years with previous positions - because it matters to me. So, yea, Artemis get. a. job. 

      57 minutes ago, Ozlsn said:

      Art lists manual labour and call centres. And that's it. Not any jobs they could look at involving writing, from editing to writing student essays for money (yes it's dodgy but people do it). Not even playing video games for money (get character to a level where they have cool stuff for someone.)  Nothing about remote work, which there is more of now, and not even entry level white collar work.

      On the one hand I agree with them that the social support is inadequate, and that detailing your medical needs shouldn't have to happen - but they just grifted nearly $5000 to move and for a holiday, and with the amount of effort that took they probably could have held down employment of some description and to be honest would probably be better off.

      So many WFH/remote legit jobs now. Hell, you can play games on your phone and earn gift cards; donate blood and get gift cards. I knew a homeless couple that donated plasma for higher amount g.c.

      Absolutely! The amount of money; it's disgusting. And that amount of effort... At some point, even we don't want to or circumstances we don't want to deal with and adult, because... We're adults! Plenty of things I want to ignore or not deal with, just have go away but persevere because the alternative... not an option.

      2 hours ago, Bookworm1564 said:

      My all-time favourite Art post is the one where they say “Just for today, you can double the impact of your support with this opportunity” as if this was the moment we were all waiting for.

      Like a sale for limited-time-only 🤣

    • justpassingthru

      Posted (edited)

      So another page shared the Lott's story and this is a comment on that post. People believe "Fundy Snark" is a person. There are at least a couple other comments that refer to the sub as a person

      Screenshot_20240726_191210_Instagram.jpg

       

      Screenshot_20240726_191619_Instagram.jpg

      Edited by justpassingthru
      • Upvote 1


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.