Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    84,845

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

Worldly Distractions: Girls 3.10 - Role Play


crazyforkate

412 views

blog-girlsrp.jpg 

girlsrp

While our lives spin out of control, we cling to those people we think can keep us going. If you're a cast member of Girls, unfortunately, that person is likely an asshole. Sit back and enjoy the ride, guys.

Previously on: Grandma dies and Adam is an actor. Also, they're pretending to be engaged while Grandma's still alive, which causes some uncomfortable conversations.

Hannah gets drunk with friends (mostly colleagues, I think) while begging Adam to come to the bar and join them. She winds up barfing everywhere while "99 Luftballons" plays. They get her into a cab. Joe goes with her and holds her hair while she pukes. Opening title.

Hannah wakes up at Joe's. Marnie goes to see her old college friend, Soojin, a trust fund baby opening her own gallery and famous for saying super-annoying things. There's an opening at the gallery, but to Marnie's dismay, it's as Soojin's assistant.

Hannah returns to Adam, apologetic over her absence and frequent drunk texts. He is remarkably unfazed. She takes this as a sign that he doesn't worry about her. He babbles on about his play and his show coat, which he has brought home to "break in". In fact, Adam pays no attention to her whatsoever during the next few scenes.

Marnie makes beautiful music with Desi, Adam's douchey actor friend from a couple of episodes back. He mostly seems interested in getting into her pants, but does appreciate her talent. Eventually, he comes on to her through song, then launches into a sad story about his long-distance girlfriend.

Jessa and Jasper are still having an affair, and still constantly high. They are also still living with Shoshana, who does not take kindly to their interruptions when she's studying for exams.

Hannah shows up at rehearsal, where the director promptly asks her to leave. Even though Adam was the one who instigated it, he does not stick up for her, and indeed blames her when the director gets pissy. She wanders around sadly, then goes to eat chocolates and complain with Elijah. Hannah decides to spice things up. When Adam calls, she tells him to meet her at a certain place, but behaves pretty mysteriously.

Shoshana takes Jessa and Jasper out for dinner, where she springs Jasper's daughter on them. That's right, no warning whatsoever for the estranged dad. Solid plan there, Shosh. It ends in a blowup argument, as one might have predicted.

Wearing a blonde wig that wouldn't look out of place in a sci-fi version of Mad Men, Hannah waits at the bar. He's a little slow to catch on, but eventually goes for it. She blabs on about her husband "Marthaniel"  and behaves as the world's most awkward seductress. Also, her husband changes name to Jardaniel. She throws a drink in his face and they carry it on into the streets. They are forced to break character when a guy thinks Adam's assaulting her. However, Hannah refuses to let the facade drop, and Adam winds up getting punched for being a woman-beater.

The meeting with Jasper and his daughter Dot (Felicity Jones) continues to go badly. Jessa makes it worse. Dot gives a long lament about the father Jasper could be. Jessa dismisses it and chews out Shoshana for interfering. Shoshana, for her part, extols Dot's virtues. Jasper is overcome by his daughter's success and tries to reconcile. Dot says sure, if Jasper ditches Jessa - not because she's a drug addict, but because she's a terrible person.

Adam and Hannah have miraculously managed to get back in the mood, and have retreated to Marnie's for their magic love affair. Adam finds it decidedly unromantic. Also, is anyone else disturbed that he just happens to have a switchblade on him?

Hannah gets super naked, wearing weird ribbon-like underwear, and they play out a weird scene with strawberries. "You have to take the whole part or nothing," Adam says. Ookay, you kids have fun.

Jessa is forlorn and Shoshana guilty. It's clear where Jasper has chosen to go. Adam and Hannah continue to have weird fantasies, which continue into all kinds of erotic genres. Adam even calls her out, telling her it makes "no narrative sense". They argue about how things had changed. The sex isn't as dangerous, the relationship totally different. "You have an old idea of who I am," he says. Since they've fallen in love, he claims, he's okay with sweet and boring life. They come back to his play, which is consuming Adam. He tells her that to avoid drama and concentrate on work, he's going to move in with Ray for a while. He walks out, leaving Hannah alone.

Bitter and sad, this episode was the result of a lot of buildup for both Jessa and Hannah. The Hannah-Adam train, which has been troubled for a while, finally came to a crash. Jessa also lost her companion and admitted her fall back into drugs, which is a lot considering how in-denial she can be. Overall, I thought that the episode was masterfully executed, especially the scenes involving the sad, hilarious, and perpetually unconvincing roleplay. I would go so far as to call it one of the top episodes of the season. Kudos, cast and crew, and until next week.

FJ Discussion Thread

 

 

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • GuineaPigCourtship

      Posted

      My brother was diagnosed with Asbergers as a child and probably also ADD because they put him on ritalin.  He loved it because he could totally focus and do his work but he developed some sort of shoulder shrugging tic on it so they stopped it and never did anything else.  As a recently-turned 40yo he is still dealing with a lifetime of thinking he was stupid and incompetent because he couldn't learn or work in a traditional way.  He is a TREASURE of a human being whose life has been made immeasurably more difficult because no one really followed up or took his issues seriously.  I don't know if he'll ever seek help for it as an adult but I wish he would - he still thinks it's possible everyone else in the world knows how other people work and nobody will just tell him.

    • noseybutt

      Posted

      16 minutes ago, JermajestyDuggar said:

      The thing is her parents are emotionally and physically abusive. And they write books teaching it. So who knows what she considers abuse. When you grow up surrounded in normalized abuse, how can you see abuse for what it is?

      There is complexity here in that she is deeply self-centered and probably unable to recognize abusive behavior in herself and in others, both.

      I may have the story wrong, but it sounds like she returned to her parent’s property after her divorce which is…bizarre. Her enmeshment with her oldest son is also bizarre. 

      And now this rewriting of history that crosses over from bizarre to totally enraging.

      It’s a mix of poor boundaries and a diva complex that IMO makes it impossible to believe what she says. (And I say that recognizing there could have been abuse. There could also be a husband tired of the crazy and pushing back for the sake of the children and that might have felt abusive to her. Or some mix of both.)

       

      30 minutes ago, Giraffe said:

      That's what makes this worse than if she were trying to actually soften their earlier teachings. She's not. She's outright claiming now, in 2024, men are beating their wives and those abused wives aren't who their books were written for. Those abused wives - THOSE DEAD CHILDREN - are literally who they wrote their books for! 


      How many women did they privately shame into staying with their abuser? How many women over the DECADES did they tell to "just try harder," and "open your legs more often," and "if you were as submissive to him as you're telling us you are he wouldn't have beat you. You need to stop lying to yourself and to him and god will bless your marriage"?

      HOW. MANY. WOMEN?

      How many women did you, Debi, counsel to accept being raped as a normal part of marriage? 
       

      And how many more abused children that never died and so we never heard your book was found in their parents bedrooms? HOW DARE YOU LIE AND MAKE YOURSELF SEEM INNOCENT!

      I want to add that most of the dead children were adopted. They were kids already traumatized. I share your rage.

      • I Agree 1
    • Giraffe

      Posted (edited)

      3 hours ago, JermajestyDuggar said:

      This makes me much more angry than just ignoring the usual criticism. They are gaslighting, denying, and pretending like they had no idea there were men who beat the shit out of their wives when writing their heinous books. 
       

      Debi, “what?!? You mean there are men who beat women? I’ve never heard of such a thing!” 
       

      Fuck off.

      That's what makes this worse than if she were trying to actually soften their earlier teachings. She's not. She's outright claiming now, in 2024, men are beating their wives and those abused wives aren't who their books were written for. Those abused wives - THOSE DEAD CHILDREN - are literally who they wrote their books for! 


      How many women did they privately shame into staying with their abuser? How many women over the DECADES did they tell to "just try harder," and "open your legs more often," and "if you were as submissive to him as you're telling us you are he wouldn't have beat you. You need to stop lying to yourself and to him and god will bless your marriage"?

      HOW. MANY. WOMEN?

      How many women did you, Debi, counsel to accept being raped as a normal part of marriage? 
       

      And how many more abused children that never died and so we never heard your book was found in their parents bedrooms? HOW DARE YOU LIE AND MAKE YOURSELF SEEM INNOCENT!

      Edited by Giraffe
      • Upvote 1
      • Sad 1
      • I Agree 1
    • JermajestyDuggar

      Posted

      The thing is her parents are emotionally and physically abusive. And they write books teaching it. So who knows what she considers abuse. When you grow up surrounded in normalized abuse, how can you see abuse for what it is?

      • Upvote 2
    • TrueRebel1

      Posted

      42 minutes ago, Ozlsn said:

      Has Shoshanna come out and said that her marriage was abusive, or is it being heavily implied? 

      She's used the words abuse and darkness but hasn't detailed specifics or physical abuse. 

      It's interesting to me that the court saw fit to give James 50% custody of the kids, and that he held enough sway to win the choice of public school. I'm not saying that there couldn't have been abuse, especially emotional abuse, but the way Shoshanna has painted the narrative is that he was so abusive that the stress gave Jeremiah seizures and that he was abusive enough to warrant divorce which should (according to the Pearl's beliefs) basically mean he was beating her within an inch of her life. 

      • Thank You 1


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.