Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    84,578

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

The Phantom Tollbooth Reread: Chapters 5 & 6


Maggie Mae

1,737 views

Chapter 5: Short Shrift

I’ll admit it. I had to look up the definition of “Short Shrift.”

1.       Rapid and unsympathetic dismissal; curt treatment.

1.1. Archaic Little time between condemnation and execution or punishment.

Also of interest is the definition of “shrift”

                Archaic

1.       Confession, especially to a priest.

1.1   Absolution by a priest.

Anyway, so the marketplace that sells physical words is in shambles. Words are all jumbled together and flying everywhere. No one in the area is able to speak properly and the dialogue matches. Eventually, though, the mess is swept up and people start to sort their words. The Spelling Bee flew off and as Milo stood up the entire police of Dictionopolis arrives, blowing his whistle. Yup. The entire police force is one person, “Officer Shrift.” Officer Shrift is short.  Two feet tall and twice as wide, to be exact. He blew his whistle until he was red, and then started shouting at everyone. He informs Milo and Tock that it’s disrespectful to sound your alarm in the presence of a policeman.

The Humbug tries to assure Officer Shift that he is not guilty and inadvertently places the blame on Milo. The officer, who is biased against little boys, asks Milo bunch of pointless questions that have nothing to do with anything, and throws Milo and Tock in jail for six million years. I was going to say something about how Milo didn’t even have his Miranda rights read to him, but then I realized that this book predates Miranda vs Arizona.

Fortunately, Office Shift doesn’t literally throw them in jail, as the jail appears to have a lot of steps to travel down into a dungeon. Milo and Tock are warned about a witch as the officer leaves them, with a “see you in six million years.”

The “witch” turns out to be a “Which” instead of a “witch” and her name is Faintly Macabre. She is the king’s great-aunt. She used to be in charge of choosing which words were to be used for occasions. She worked hard at her job until the power corrupted her and she hoarded words and convinced everyone that “Silence is Golden,” which caused Dictionopolis to fall into an economic recession and destroyed their main industry. The King found out and threw her in jail, and they have not yet replaced that position.

Milo offers Faintly help, but she says the only thing that can help is the return of Rhyme and Reason.

Thoughts:  

I had something here about Puritan culture and Fundamental Christians and the "choose words wisely" proverb morphing into "Silence is Golden." But I'm not really sure what I was getting at, so I'll just throw that half-formed idea out there and let someone else go with it. 

 

 

Chapter 6: Faintly Macabre’s Story

Faintly Macabre tells Milo and Tock the history of Westeros The Lands Beyond. It was a terrible place until one day some prince showed up. There was a battle between goodness and the demons, monsters, and giants. Eventually that was resolved and he had some land to build a city. The city grew and became the kingdom of Wisdom.
The Prince became a King and married and had two boys. He told them to build new cities in the wilderness for some stupid reason, I guess to keep these demons and monsters away. So one brother build Dictionopolis and the other built Digitopolis. Guess which one is the city of words and which is the city of numbers. Go one. Guess. Take a minute.

Got it?

Digitopolis is the city of numbers! Shocking, I know. It’s located in the Mountains of Ignorance.

It turns out the brothers aren’t very good friends and they fought about which is more important, words or numbers.

The old king, one day, disappointed that he didn’t have a daughter, found some girls in the garden. While I appreciate the nod to the tale of Romulus and Remus and/or Moses, I find it highly suspect that someone would just leave some twin girls in a basket in some random rich person’s garden.  The girls were blonde, because of course beautiful girls are blonde. (Someday children’s literature will consider dirty blonde/reddish/light brown/frizzy/wavy hair to be beautiful. Someday.) These supposed supermodel orphans were adopted by the king and called “Rhyme” and “Reason.” Because why not?

Eventually, the King died and the Kingdom was split between the two sons. Azaz (in Dictionopolis) and Mathemagician (Digitopolis). They provided for their adopted sisters and often called upon them to settle disputes.

Azaz the Unabridged and the Mathmagician had a huge fight. They asked R&R once again which is more important – numbers or words? And they were like “um, both, dumbasses.” So the brothers finally agreed on something, and banished Rhyme and Reason to the Castle in the Air.

Milo and Tock discuss going to rescue them, and the Which tries to dissuade them, as it will be difficult and there will be demons. She shows them the way out of prison, and as Milo and Tock leave, they are greeted again by the King’s advisors, who say the Royal Banquet is about to begin.

 

Thoughts:

I don’t think this story is just a history of the Lands Beyond. I think it’s more of a discussion of real world discussions in all levels of education. Should we focus on Language or STEM? There are other, smaller cities/towns in the Lands, as well, but we’ll get to them later. How about we teach kids like Milo both math and literature? Having a good vocabulary and the ability to communicate is just as important as being able to calculate the cost of your mortgage. Rhyme and Reason, despite pissing me off with their superhuman good looks and ability to be raised in a castle despite being left for dead by some random peasant, are literal representations of, well, rhyme and reason. Or common sense. So Milo is going to go save the world! (Or at least the Lands Beyond.) How fun!  

Also, my spell check HATES me right now. Imaginary words!

 

  • Upvote 1

1 Comment


Recommended Comments

Totally enjoying these. I read The Phantom Tollbooth too young (because I have always been a precocious bugger) but because of that, I missed a lot of the puns. 

I was thinking about gifts to give my 7-year-old niece for Christmas and learned from my mistake :) Little House in the Big Woods it is, instead (and Harriet the Spy for the naughty niece).

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • thoughtful

      Posted (edited)

      I keep meaning to post something about Tennessee Brando here - every time I watch one of his videos, I think of Bro Gary and his buddies, because, while his accent is different, he uses a lot of the same southernisms as Gary. It's like he's redeeming the whole southeastern US for me (he's a progressive Democrat who talks about politics).

      This video seemed especially apt - it's his take on the evangelical pastor who came out against the Trump bible.

      Spoiler

       

      There's so much the pastor says, and so much about his style, that would be right up Gary's alley. But he's Pentecostal, his church is large, and it looks like they do the worship music stuff that Gary hates - no smokestacks, though.

      Now, if Pastor Baker came out against Trump and his bible, that would blow Gary's mind.

      Edited by thoughtful
    • JMO

      Posted (edited)

      @ToriAmos could be, maybe we'll find out for sure soon. 

      Edited by JMO
    • ToriAmos

      Posted

      20 hours ago, JMO said:

      Per story on Kress's IG, Rachel Morton had her baby. Born the same day as Issa.

      Could Kress be talking about Addie or Francesca’s baby being born on Isa’s birthday? The baby (boy?) on Rachel’s lap looks bigger than newborn. Maybe it was born at the start of April?

      • Upvote 1
    • dawn9476

      Posted (edited)

      It looks like joy may not have been there because of health problems with their family. They went camping with Austin's family and had a terrible time. Austin had breathing issues because of his Asthma. Gideon was also having breathing issues, which was officially diagnosed as Asthma when Joy took him to the doctor when they got back. The baby was cutting a tooth, which it why he was being fussy. I think joy had her own allergy issues because of all pollen. All the pollen may have made the baby fussy, too, in addition to him cutting a tooth. I guess they picked the wrong weekend to go because they go camping a lot and seem to always have a good time..

      Edited by dawn9476
    • JermajestyDuggar

      Posted

      8 minutes ago, Giraffe said:

      Hard agree. This is so many of the families I snark on. I have a number of friends who are over having newborns and toddlers and young children in general. And you know what they did as a response to that? They stopped having children! One friend was always a one an done. But another friend became a one and done after going through life with a newborn and realized she could not cope with dealing with that again. So she didn't! 

      I’m the same age as Braggie and I was so glad to be over the baby toddler stage. Her girl twins are the same age as my older son and her son Theo is the same age as my younger son. And she’s had 4 kids since having this kids. I would be so miserable and phoning everything in. If I had 4 more kids. I’m so glad I can focus on my 2 kids and enjoy parenting them. 

      • Upvote 4
      • Love 1


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.