Jump to content
  • Sky
  • Blueberry
  • Slate
  • Blackcurrant
  • Watermelon
  • Strawberry
  • Orange
  • Banana
  • Apple
  • Emerald
  • Chocolate
  • Charcoal

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 86
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2
Maggie Mae

I just wanted to say THANK YOU to everyone for reading this! I've appreciated every comment. 

Message added by Maggie Mae

Flowers in the Attic: "Endings, Beginnings" and "Epilogue"

Maggie Mae

562 views

Endings, Beginnings

In the last chapter, we were left with a cliff hanger. Cathy was braced for the "knockout blow" of bad news that Chris alluded to, but didn't share. He was too busy describing the sex that John the Butler and a woman named Livvy had on the sofa he hid behind. He also described the Grandfather's library, right down to the placement of the furniture. 

Chris asks Cathy to guess the reason that "she" (I think he's referring to the grandmother) gave for not having the children's room cleaned. Cathy shakes her head instead of speaking. She also mentions that it had been so long since the servants stopped coming, she had forgotten those first horrible weeks. 

Chris says: 

Quote

Capture.thumb.PNG.49f8b97f2195bc8c37e70932672f3848.PNG

He then explains it out to her- Arsenic is white. And even more, he points out that you can mix it with powdered sugar, and put it on donuts. 

Cathy is still skeptical. She wonders, much like @HerNameIsBuffy, why the Grandmother didn't just poison them outright. 

Meanwhile, Chris is "cupping" Cathy's head between his palms. 

He then tells her the plot to "Arsenic and Old Lace," but doesn't say the name of the film. I've seen the play once or twice, I find it quite funny. I should look for the film. 

Our narrator is shocked. She asks if Cory died of arsenic poisoning. After all, Corrine said it was pneumonia. Chris than (kind of selfishly), hurts Cathy a little more, by pointing out that: 

  1. Momma can say whatever she wants, doesn't mean it's true
  2. Cory might not have even been taken to a hospital. 

They decide to test the arsenic doughnut theory on the mouse. 

***

The mouse dies a painful death. 

They decide to put the mouse and two doughnuts into a bag for the police. Cathy suspects Chris is hiding something. He says he'll tell her later, he can't say anything more without vomiting. 

*** 

Cathy compares her life to a soap opera. While she is doing this, the Grandmother pops in for a final visit. She leaves them with some advice. 

Quote

Nothing ever works out the way you think it will. In the end, you are always disappointed. 

Chatty Cathy monologues to herself about happiness, being a woman grown, feeling older than the mountains outside, her happiness being a hill, I don't know.  "The wisdom of the attic was in my bones, etched on my brain, part of my flesh." 

"Where was that fragile, golden-fair Dresden doll I used to be? Gone. Gone like porcelain turned into steel - made into someone who would always get what she wanted, no matter who or what stood in her way." 

Cathy forces Carrie to eat, takes her to the bathroom, cleans and dresses her. They both dress in several layers of warm clothing. Cathy is wearing a fourteen-karat-gold watch from Switzerland. Chris has a watch. They have a guitar, a banjo, a polaroid, and watercolors, and the wedding rings. Cathy takes this moment to realize that the Grandmother could open the door and watch them without them noticing (good, god, children, be more observant), and could she know? Would she be preventing their escape?  

Considering this is the last chapter, I'm going to go ahead and call it. No. The Grandmother is not going to prevent their escape. I think she only appeared here as part of the good-bye tour. 

Our hero runs upstairs to say good-bye to the attic, and write on the chalkboard. How did they not run out of chalk in four years? 

***

They leave with two suitcases, the guitar and banjo, Carrie, a dead mouse, and two doughnuts. They split the money between the two suitcases. It's not yet snowing. Cathy smells the clean air and feels the ground below her feet. She puts Carrie down and Chris yells at them to hurry up. Carrie (sniff) asks if they will meet Cory. 

Cathy lies. She tells Carrie that Cory is waiting for them, with Daddy in a garden. Carrie worries about Cory not liking the garden if she's not there. 

This kind of goes on, Cathy is sad, but lies to Carrie to get her to walk faster. Chris keeps telling them to hurry, I guess because VC needed to create a sense of urgency. If they miss the morning train, they have to wait until 4, and will likely be caught by the Grandmother. 

I want to know what ole concrete boobs does and says when she goes up and finds them gone. Does she have a little smile? Is she angry? Does she grab her henchman and tear off in a Rolls Royce to track them down? 

Spoiler

882724043_giphy(4).gif.3dc990baafad2c5bfe9038cfb29f0fd9.gif

Spoiler

1552473953_giphy(5).gif.9c021e322cf48877bcfb487e841a698c.gif

They arrive at the train station. 

The ginger mail man greets them and says that Carrie looks "peaked" which I guess means tired or sick? They say she's been sick. Chris buys tickets. They get on the train, and Cathy watches the mansion. She sees a "shadowy, distant form of a large old woman" who appears and vanishes. Didn't it take hours to walk to the mansion? How can you see the shape of a person inside if they are hours away?

They slide down in their seat anyway, just in case. Cathy then wonders why she's up there so early.

***

They make it to Charlottesville, where they buy bus tickets to Sarasota. They have two hours to wait.  Worried about the Butler, they stash their stuff in a locker and wander around. 

Chris decides to tell the rest of the story while holding up the dead mouse sack. He "overheard the servants talking." Was this part of the same night? Was it John and Livvy again? Or did he go spy on other servants? We will never know. 

Whatever, on the night that shall be called "deus ex machina" when all of the servants gossiped within hearing distance of Christopher Jr, he overheard them discussing a codicil that was added to the grandfather's will. 

273850659_Capture2.thumb.PNG.36b5b0aecfe8de0f2e3383044c92a2cc.PNG

It doesn't work like that. Corrine, you married a lawyer. Bart, you married a conflict of interest. Everyone stop it. 

Chris doesn't think that concrete boobs is evil, because she prays before bed. Chris, I would like to introduce you to Free Jinger. He also thinks that Grandmother telling them not to eat the sweets is a clue that she wasn't trying to kill them. Christopher is an idiot and should not be a doctor. 

He finally apologizes to Cathy for not wanting to leave and believing in Corrine. He then tasks her with the responsibility to choose what to do with the dead mouse and arsenic donuts, because he's still a manipulative asshole. 

Cathy/VC Andrews moralizes at us a bit. 

Quote

They'd be only gray mice in cages, shut up like us, only they'd have the benefit of being in the company of drug addicts, prostitutes, and other killers like themselves. Their clothes would be gray prison cotton. To trips twice a week to the beauty salon for Momma, no makeup, no professional manicures - and a shower once a week. 

Ah, yes, sharing space with a drug addict and a prostitute! 

Spoiler

1811577715_giphy(6).gif.759828059f4e5abea374af707be0f026.gif

After a page of hemming and hawing, Cathy makes a decision to throw the "evidence" away. 

And that's it. 

______________

Epilogue

The epilogue is four paragraphs. Five sentences, total.  She considers the previous story to be "their foundation years" of which they base the rest of their lives. They continue to move toward their goals. Carrie has a hard time without Cory. They survive, but that's another story. 

_______________

 

My thoughts. (Pretty randomly thrown at the page) 

I started this book over a year and a half ago. Rereading as an adult, I'm struck by how much I must have missed or forgotten as a child. I remembered bits and pieces of it, but had managed to forget the weird religious aspect of it. 

Much of this book was a slog, and that makes me wonder if the monotony of some of the middle chapters was done intentionally. If the "dolls" had to endure day after day after day of doing nothing, I suppose we can read about it, right? I wish there had been more "showing" and less "telling." I also wonder how much better this book could be with a third person POV, or even multiple narrators. 

Medical science is pretty clear that "sun" doesn't make children grow. Though I am concerned about their vitamin d levels & anemia. 

Is VC Andrews obsessed with appearance, or was that a choice to show Cathy's character? 

Now that Corrine has moved out of Foxworth Hall, would the kids have been allotted more freedom and fewer arsenic doughnuts? I imagine they had to remain hidden. Or would concrete boobs use them as leverage to get her money back? How much is property tax in Virginia and do they have a trust?

How is Christopher going to be a doctor? He's terrible. He lacks curiosity and doesn't seem to care about people. 

All of these kids will have life long psychological issues. I'm sure that will be handled in an appropriate fashion in the next book. 

I'm half tempted to write VC Andrews fanfiction, where I take them, give them new names that start with different letters, modern attitudes and language, curiosity, and Cory lives, and the adults go to jail. 

Anyway. I don't know what to do next. I started to read Petals On the Wind, and I thought "wow, this is so much more interesting!" But at 25% through, it's already turning from "this could be really interesting" to "ugh, Cathy is annoying" and a lot of way too fast timeline things. I also hate the narrator and don't find her very interesting. At least in Game of Thrones, I can hate Cersei, and know that she's being written that way, and she's interesting. Cathy is not a schemer. I don't care about her thoughts on emerald bathtubs. 

 

  • Upvote 1
  • Thank You 9


7 Comments


Recommended Comments

FloraDoraDolly

Posted

Quote

All of these kids will have life long psychological issues. I'm sure that will be handled in an appropriate fashion in the next book. 

Yes, they do.

No, they're not.

Share this comment


Link to comment
GreyhoundFan

Posted

Quote

Chris doesn't think that concrete boobs is evil, because she prays before bed. Chris, I would like to introduce you to Free Jinger.

I laughed out loud at this. Thank you!

Quote

Anyway. I don't know what to do next. I started to read Petals On the Wind, and I thought "wow, this is so much more interesting!" But at 25% through, it's already turning from "this could be really interesting" to "ugh, Cathy is annoying" and a lot of way too fast timeline things. I also hate the narrator and don't find her very interesting.

Petals On The Wind drove me crazy for a different reason than FITA. More than once, I found myself shouting at Cathy to get the hell away from Julian. He was some of the worst news in a series of books about bad news.

Share this comment


Link to comment
JordynDarby5

Posted (edited)

Petals on the Wind drove me crazy too. More then FITA because the kids get zero therapy for what they gone through and are still clearly still traumatized. Be we get Dr. Paul the Pervert and rapist mooning over Cathy and behaving inappropriate towards Cathy while shoving poor Carrie into a boarding school, Julian who beats Cathy, rapes her and molested or raped Carrie (Carrie didn't clarify what he did to her), Bart who raped Cathy and made remarks that he may have raped Corrine. It also makes me wonder about VC Andrews at adding three rapists to the book. Cathy flip flops from driving me crazy to seeing how damage she really is. Like hoarding food. While its the slowest moving revenge ever I do like that at least someone stays angry and wants revenge. Carrie's too traumatized and Chris lets it go Cathy thinks he's still protecting Corrine and so do I. I love that book mostly for two things Cathy making good on her threat on Grandmother by showing up and whipping her. And her exposing Corrine starting with descending the stairs at Christmas and destroying all of Corrine's attempts to get herself out of it. I do wish it hadn't taken so long or maybe we could have seen her doing other stuff as revenge.  

Edited by JordynDarby5

Share this comment


Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

Petals has a lot of snarkworthy recap material in it. The next two books, not so much because they focus on Cathy's creepy son, Bart. Garden of Shadows is kind of all over the place, since VC Andrews started it but then died before it was finished, which means it's mainly the work of the ghostwriter. I don't think the Olivia character (a.k.a. the grandmother) comes off as crazy enough. Yeah, she's narrating the story, so of course she will portray herself in the best light possible. But here, she is mostly stern, calculating, and disappointed with the way her marriage turned out, whereas in Flowers... well, y'all know what she was like in that book.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Destiny

Posted

OMFG that creepy asshole kid. I quit reading the whole mess about the time he tortured his dog to death, and of course Cathy and Chris were too self absorbed to notice. I hate ALL OF THEM. 

Share this comment


Link to comment
JordynDarby5

Posted

3 hours ago, FloraDoraDolly said:

Petals has a lot of snarkworthy recap material in it. The next two books, not so much because they focus on Cathy's creepy son, Bart. Garden of Shadows is kind of all over the place, since VC Andrews started it but then died before it was finished, which means it's mainly the work of the ghostwriter. I don't think the Olivia character (a.k.a. the grandmother) comes off as crazy enough. Yeah, she's narrating the story, so of course she will portray herself in the best light possible. But here, she is mostly stern, calculating, and disappointed with the way her marriage turned out, whereas in Flowers... well, y'all know what she was like in that book.

Yes, it does. The other too I agree not so much. Mostly because of Bart. I hate Bart.  Olivia doesn't start off creepy in the last book. By the end I still wasn't sure how she got to that point. She marries Malcolm very quickly and only realizes after she marries him that he's a psycho. And doesn't do anything. She just stays. I'm not sure why. Any feelings she had fade very fast and seems to hate him for most of the book.  I'm not even sure you could blame the era since she was raised mostly by her father who let her do his books. There's really no reason why Olivia can't just leave once she realized she married an psycho. I'm not entirely sure abusive wife makes works with her because she never comes off like one. Or being stuck because her father wills all his money to her. 

52 minutes ago, Destiny said:

OMFG that creepy asshole kid. I quit reading the whole mess about the time he tortured his dog to death, and of course Cathy and Chris were too self absorbed to notice. I hate ALL OF THEM. 

Oh, yes he is. I only ever read that book once because of the poor dog and Bart being a creepy asshole and its very weird and frustrating that Cathy and Chris don't notice let alone do anything.

Share this comment


Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

On 12/22/2018 at 11:06 PM, JordynDarby5 said:

Yes, it does. The other too I agree not so much. Mostly because of Bart. I hate Bart.  Olivia doesn't start off creepy in the last book. By the end I still wasn't sure how she got to that point. She marries Malcolm very quickly and only realizes after she marries him that he's a psycho. And doesn't do anything. She just stays. I'm not sure why. Any feelings she had fade very fast and seems to hate him for most of the book.  I'm not even sure you could blame the era since she was raised mostly by her father who let her do his books. There's really no reason why Olivia can't just leave once she realized she married an psycho. I'm not entirely sure abusive wife makes works with her because she never comes off like one. Or being stuck because her father wills all his money to her.

Olivia was a very religious woman, although much less fanatical in this book than in Flowers. None of the books ever actually say which denomination the Foxworths ascribed to. While they didn't seem to be Catholic, in those days divorce would have been frowned upon in any Christian denomination-- as it is today in the fundie sects that are the focus of Free Jinger. At the time of Garden, there was also a very strong social stigma toward women who were divorced. While Olivia didn't seem to care much for the wealthy socialites who came to the Foxworth Christmas party every year, I think she would have wanted to shield her children from the stigma that would have resulted from having divorced parents. Also, I can see Malcolm doing whatever he could to take (and keep) the kids away from her, even though he couldn't stand either one of his sons. Olivia had her own money, sure, but Malcolm was still a man and this would have been the 1920s and 1930s. Of course, it would have been more interesting if the books had at least brought up these issues. But Malcolm became sickly at a rather young age anyhow, and after that Olivia just did whatever she wanted.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • TatiFish9

      Posted

      On 1/16/2019 at 10:17 PM, Vivi_music said:

       But I can't seem to remember seeing Jana and Jill often together since Jill moved out. I know Jill isn't on the show anymore but from what we see on social media, she is not being shunned from her family completly. She is seen with her younger siblings often, she posted about visiting Jessa for play dates with the cousins and she was at the TTH for the ugly Christmas sweater thing. But her and Jana together? I can't seem to recall. 

      @luv2laugh "I've always been surprised that Jana, who was known as the "BFF of Jill", is frequently hanging out with Jessa, Jinger, and Anna but I can't remember her being pictured with Jill other than at family events."

      -------

      This has been of particular interest to me. Jana was seen face timing Jill while the Dillards were in SCA. So I dont think it was a pairing thing. I am thinking there was a general interest to keep in touch ( at least on Jana's part). I suspect either Jill started giving the cold shoulder[ she said to Joy it was okay to put hub and kids first. It did not mattet what others said] or Jana changing her opinion of Jill based on things she saw of the Dillards. Laura says Jana is sassy but classy. That is a side of Jana the public has rarely seen. I could see her calling Jill out without regret.

    • WhatWouldJohnCrichtonDo?

      Posted

      3 hours ago, Red Hair, Black Dress said:

      Not the standard fundie 'marry young and pop them out every year' life plan.  But then perhaps when you are a very, very privileged fundie the normal rules and expectations don't apply to you.

      I'm no expert, but I think that there isn't a single "standard fundie" playbook. Some fundamentalists are Quiverfull. ("As many children as God gives us.") Some aren't. Some are Calvinist, or uber-Calvinist. (All children are born full of sin. "Vipers in diapers.") Some believe that children aren't responsible for their sins until they reach the "age of accountability", which can vary depending on the belief system. Some have stay at home daughters and some don't. There are lots of other variations that I can't think of right now. On FJ, we do talk about the Quiverfull, SAHD fundies more often, but they aren't the whole picture.

      I have a habit of thinking of things in analogies, and the analogy I came up with for fundie variations is pizza. At most pizza places, you can order from the menu of set recipes (say a meat lover's pizza or a super supreme pizza), or you can make your own combo from the menu. You can even order a particular recipe, but vary it a little. (Like a veggie lover's pizza with no mushrooms, or a supreme combo with extra bell peppers.) It's still all pizza.

      So, some fundies may stick to a particular recipe (IBLP association, homeschooling, Quiverfull, and an IFB church), or they may create their system à la carte. They may vary their recipes, but they're still fundies. They have a fundamentalist approach to their beliefs and to life. Whether they're Protestant fundamentalists, Catholic fundamentalists, Calvinist fundamentalists, Baptist fundamentalists, or LDS fundamentalists.  

      Anyway, sorry for the wall of text. :my_blush: And I wasn't trying to rant at you, or lecture you, @Red Hair, Black Dress. You just gave me a nice platform to dive off of. :my_smile:

    • TatiFish9

      Posted (edited)

      Seems like Lawson got caught with his hand in the cookie jar. If so, I am so glad Jana is the one to slap it out. This seems like agency on her part.

      Outside of general fundiness and all that comes with it, I don't have a problem with Lawson or his antics. I just think opportunism that rides on the coattails of a blantant lie is uncool.

      I do think something is going on with him and the Duggars. I wonder if Jana is a foil. It could be anything as minor as him working musically with the younger Duggar girls or him possibly looking to court someone close (proximity) to the Duggars. I dunno. All I know is when the rumors were out (again) about him and Jana, the most I thought it could be was unrequited interest on his end. Because I am one of the ones who kinda buys into him and Jinger in a "failed" gettingtoknow-ship. Even if he is now into Jana , I could not see her settling for it. If waiting for that very special one is what she's doing, it is difficult to believe she would give into her sister's sorta ex (from her perspective). That may not inspire *sisterly affection*😉.But who knows. Stranger things have occurred with both these families. 

      Also, there is a part of me that thinks (and hopes) Jana created this account of her own volition with the encouragment of her sisters. Maybe they are helping her break free of some of those Gen2A Fundie chastity beliefs holding her back from finding her true self and inevitably a mate. Because let's be honest, that is usually end game with them. And I don't think it is a stretch to say that.

       

       

      Edited by TatiFish9
    • hoipolloi

      Posted

      2 hours ago, MamaJunebug said:

      ”I’d rather flunk my Wasserman Test / Than read a poem by Edgar A. Guest.” 

      — Dorothy Parker

      Cackling out loud here.

      Of course, old VF snarkers will recall that Edgar A. Guest was one of Dougie's favorite poets, right up there with Rudyard Kipling.

       

      • Haha 2
    • CyborgKin

      Posted

      I had to update my location because flavoured sarcasm is too good not to share around.



×