Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    85,913

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

Elton John in Moscow - Still Standing


crazyforkate

346 views

blog-sirelton.jpg 

sirelton

This post originally appeared at my blog. I thought FJ might find it interesting. 

When I heard the Rocket Man was coming to Russia, I jumped at the chance. With the current political situation, the whole thing seemed rife for drama. In fact, in the days leading up to the show, I was a bit worried about too much drama. And having first heard of him when I was five (over Diana's death, of course), falling in love with his warm, delightful music when I was twelve, and seeing him live in Canada in 2010, I was most definitely a fan. I snapped up a ticket the second they went on sale, and though they were nosebleed seats, I couldn't have been happier about it.

The musicality this year was a huge improvement over 2010. It was in an actual theatre, not the hockey arena from my hometown, so the acoustics were better and the audience was much more - well-behaved? I don't know if that's a cultural thing. I think Russian audiences, in general, are a bit more restrained than in North America. However, they applauded enthusiastically and clearly adored the music. The opening act, two cellists from Croatia, also got a warm reception - well-deserved, of course. Their rendition of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" was not to be beat.

Some standout performances included "Rocket Man" (always one of his better numbers, though it wasn't his usual 12-minute production number), "Candle In the Wind" (into which he put his heart and soul, though I suppose he must be sick of the damned thing),  and "Someone Saved My Life Tonight" (again, one of his usual tour de forces). He also played a new song, "Oceans Away", which is about the First World War and was extraordinarily moving. For the encore, he played "Your Song" and "Crocodile Rock". The latter was what really got the audience up and partying, as he invited them to sing along with the chorus. Even the most proper audience members were dancing by the end. Interestingly, the biggest audience reaction was to "Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word", a song I would never have ranked among his most popular.

For the first two-thirds of the show, I was pretty sure he was going to be on his best behavior - it seemed like a normal concert. Apart from a few greetings and announcing the names of songs, he didn't talk much at all. He was his usual energetic self (how does a man in his late sixties manage that kind of energy?), dancing on the piano and mugging outrageously.

As the first major openly gay performer in Russia since the new law began, though, I imagine it was too big an opportunity not to pass up. He sent his band off the stage and had the video feed turned off. He faced us, and spoke about his concerns. I think that overall, he handled it very respectfully. He began by speaking of his fondness for Russia, and how he has always felt welcome here - never judged in any way. Then he stated his position very simply. He considers the new laws "inhumane" and "isolating", and expressed his sadness at what was going on. He spoke of the power of music and the harmony that comes from it, noting the thousands of people in the theatre all brought together. Harmony, according to him, is what will make the world better for his children and for Russia's. He then dedicated the concert to Vladislav Tornovoi, a young gay man murdered earlier this year in Volgograd, and finished with a hauntingly beautiful solo rendition of his classic "Nikita".

The audience reaction to this was mixed applause and heckling (more of the former, thankfully), but most of them simply listened. And that, I think, is the best he could have hoped for - listening. I can't speak for what went on in their hearts and minds, but everyone attending that night knew there was a strong chance he would say something, and when it came time, they let him state his case. He, in turn, did so respectfully, praising Russia's acceptance of him over the years and in the end, making it about the music. It was a powerful moment, and there was no doubt he meant every word, but he kept it brief and then continued to the entertainment we all loved. Beautifully handled on his part, and (mostly) respected by his audience. You can find the full text of his speech here.

Later in the show, he spoke about Nelson Mandela, with whom he was friendly, and spoke very sincerely of Mandela's impact and their personal connection. Curiously, the audience reaction to this was rather muted, but I'm not sure how Mandela was seen in Russia. He then launched into "Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me", dedicating it to Mandela and bringing down the house. With the enormous enthusiasm and musicality he threw into it, I'd call it the best number of the evening. It was truly fantastic.

When he came on for the encore, he gave a final, very short speech, thanking us for listening to his previous statement and reaffirming his love for Russia. At this point, he even got a little teary. The audience seemed more receptive to this one, since he placed it in such positive terms. Then he played two of his greatest pieces, and we returned to what  the show was all about.

He has an upcoming concert in Kazan, which means at least a few more days in Russia, so I'm a little worried about the possibility of reprisal. However, I am very glad that everything in Moscow went off without a hitch. He is an incredibly talented and entertaining performer, and the musical part of the show was outstanding. When the time came to say something, he said it simply and in a way which sent a message of support rather than of attack. His bravery in coming here and speaking out cannot be understated. He allowed room for a profound statement, both in his words and in his presence, without letting it overwhelm the show itself - a delicate balancing act which he carried off perfectly.

Thank you, Sir Elton, for coming to Russia and giving us the chance to hear you - both through your music and through the power of your words. This Canadian expat found it an extraordinary experience.

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • JermajestyDuggar

      Posted

      There was a post on social media talking about this recent interview with Ballerina Farm and asking what people think about some of the things in it. So many commenters were like, “it’s her business! It’s not your life so why do you care?” This is the type of thing that bugs me to no end. Ballerina Farm posts their lives willingly! They post their children’s lives! Of course people will speculate and care! If they didn’t put their lives all over social media none of us would know anything about them. 

    • LongTimeLurkerOG

      Posted

      On 7/25/2024 at 6:47 PM, LilMissMetaphor said:

      Just FYI in case someone missed it the first time round, this is what Art wrote on Reddit a year ago addressing some of the concerns that were brought up.  It's very telling if you read between some of the lines.

      "I don’t lie or make fraudulent claims to get money. That’s what a grifter is. I’ve closed all previous fundraisers and not all of them were successfully funded – for instance my legal name change and wedding fund did not get funded, so I still haven’t had a chance to do those things.

      I’m unable to work for a variety of medically supported reasons. It’s not okay to ask disabled people for proof of their disability simply because it’s medical information. To entertain the question is to concede that it’s okay to go ask other disabled people for their private medical history. It’s a common misconception that people pretend to be disabled for benefits or monetary gain, but it’s rare and doesn’t really make sense to do because benefits and fundraising add up to so little.

      I have been going to Seattle to look at possible places to live because it’s literally unavoidable, and I’ve been in severe pain because of it. That doesn’t mean I could do manual labor on a consistent basis. I don’t even drive, so I’ve had to cover gas and ask friends for help with rides.

      Have you ever tried working at a call center? I have. They’re severely strict and demanding, and incredibly demoralizing without paying much. They’re not an accessible alternative for people who can’t do more demanding manual labor. “Get a job like the rest of us” is ableist and is a fundamental misunderstanding of how accessible jobs are. It’s no better than yelling it at someone panhandling on the street. The supposedly “easy” or “low-skill” jobs are still difficult to do.

      I do use what resources I can, but it’s a total myth that there’s a robust social welfare system anywhere in the United States. If there was, we wouldn’t have so many hundreds of thousands of homeless people here, with millions more just a few missed paychecks away from joining them.

      The toxic mold was confirmed. My partner is literally terminally ill from it. If you read the actual updates, the name of the illness and the research surrounding it have been detailed. We have a letter from the pulmonologist that we sent to the landlord explaining that the environment my partner was in was causing the illness. Again, you’re demanding medical proof that you have no reason to ask about. Some things can’t just be washed out.

      I am as clear as I can possibly be about specific needs so that people know what they’re helping to support. I have said again and again that people shouldn’t give unless they can spare it and want to help. I even said that in the post linked to in this comment thread. My patreon is explicitly to support my writing.

      So why am I still fundraising and making money off telling my story? Because I literally have no other real options. I’ve been formally diagnosed with PTSD, it’s not “alleged trauma.” If it was working all that well, I wouldn’t have to keep detailing my needs.

      The real grifters in our society are billionaires, not poor disabled people. You sound like you just hate us for trying to exist."

      I remember reading this before. Well, they can take all their reasons and Stop. Grifting. Plenty of people with disabilities work and /or receive assistance (as I mentioned previously, my exPOS, who has disabilities so I'm familiar with a number of options and money). Some family, have / had disabilities. I've been an advocate for services and staff training (and provided training) for Years with previous positions - because it matters to me. So, yea, Artemis get. a. job. 

      57 minutes ago, Ozlsn said:

      Art lists manual labour and call centres. And that's it. Not any jobs they could look at involving writing, from editing to writing student essays for money (yes it's dodgy but people do it). Not even playing video games for money (get character to a level where they have cool stuff for someone.)  Nothing about remote work, which there is more of now, and not even entry level white collar work.

      On the one hand I agree with them that the social support is inadequate, and that detailing your medical needs shouldn't have to happen - but they just grifted nearly $5000 to move and for a holiday, and with the amount of effort that took they probably could have held down employment of some description and to be honest would probably be better off.

      So many WFH/remote legit jobs now. Hell, you can play games on your phone and earn gift cards; donate blood and get gift cards. I knew a homeless couple that donated plasma for higher amount g.c.

      Absolutely! The amount of money; it's disgusting. And that amount of effort... At some point, even we don't want to or circumstances we don't want to deal with and adult, because... We're adults! Plenty of things I want to ignore or not deal with, just have go away but persevere because the alternative... not an option.

      2 hours ago, Bookworm1564 said:

      My all-time favourite Art post is the one where they say “Just for today, you can double the impact of your support with this opportunity” as if this was the moment we were all waiting for.

      Like a sale for limited-time-only 🤣

    • justpassingthru

      Posted (edited)

      So another page shared the Lott's story and this is a comment on that post. People believe "Fundy Snark" is a person. There are at least a couple other comments that refer to the sub as a person

      Screenshot_20240726_191210_Instagram.jpg

       

      Screenshot_20240726_191619_Instagram.jpg

      Edited by justpassingthru
    • Ozlsn

      Posted

      6 hours ago, AverageGiraffe said:

      This woman makes me especially sad. She reminds me a lot of Alyssa Ann (Wakefield) Welch, of the now defunct resolved2worship xanga. A couple of years ago I re-read through the entire thing on the wayback machine, after she did an interview about her abusive marriage, and I see a lot of the same dynamics in this family. I can't put my finger on exactly why this particular woman reminds me of her, and to be fair I haven't consumed any of their content directly, just read the interview article that was posted, but for some reason I feel so sad for her. 

      It reads like at the very least an extremely controlling relationship and I would say abusive. The egg apron could have been a funny gift - if tickets to Greece were in the front pocket. If they weren't they were just an on camera reminder to her that she is subservient to his desires and that he is in control.

      3 hours ago, JermajestyDuggar said:

      Oh I’m sure she has access to credit cards. But I would be she can only buy stuff that he thinks fits their “homestead” life.

      It wouldn't surprise me if they're set up so he has to approve any transaction to be honest. 

      • Upvote 2
    • thoughtful

      Posted

      13 minutes ago, Ozlsn said:

      (also is Vance's wife in there at all?)

      Of course not!

      • Upvote 1
      • Eyeroll 1


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.