Jump to content

FJ Reviews & Recaps

  • entries
    488
  • comments
    466
  • views
    84,455

Contributors to this blog

  • crazyforkate 304
  • Maggie Mae 97
  • jinjy2 35
  • MarblesMom 33
  • Curious 9
  • GolightlyGrrl 8
  • kunoichi66 2

Game of Thrones Reread: Tyrion II


Maggie Mae

1,571 views

Chapter 13: Tyrion

Tyrion travels north and talks with Jon Snow.

 

Location:

The Kingsroad, north of Winterfell, south of The Wall.

 

Characters Present:

  • Tyrion Lannister: A dwarf, two different colored eyes.
  • Benjen Stark: Eddard Stark’s brother serves in the Night’s Watch.  Not a fan of Lannisters.
  • Jon Snow: Eddard Stark’s “bastard.” Traveling to “Take the Black” aka, pledge to protect the realm.  14.
  • Yoren: Stooped and sinister. Has a beard. Brother of the Night’s Watch. Has a “twisted shoulder” and a sour smell. He is dirty and greasy, with patched old unwashed clothing.
  • Morrec: One of Tyrion’s men.

     

Recap:

Tyrion travels north with Benjen Stark and Jon Snow. We get a bit of world building. Lots of descriptions as the weather & ground grow colder. The trees get darker, and Tyrion feels unsettled by Ghost, Jon’s direwolf. Benjen, Jon, Tyrion, and two unnamed Lannister servants/men meet up with Yoren and two peasant boys from the fingers, who are “rapers.”  They also were bringing twenty horses and a cage of ravens from Winterfell to the Wall.

 

Tyrion has brought his warmest clothing, but it is still not warm enough, and he borrows a riding fur from Benjen. We learn that the Lannisters never decline, graciously or otherwise, they take what is offered.  Tyrion, despite the gymnastic skills he showed us in a previous chapter, is too hobbled and small to be useful. So he goes off to read every night while the other men create shelter and feed the horses. Nice.

 

Tyrion has taken some books from the Winterfell library as well. One is a book on the history and properties of dragons. He reads about the properties of Dragonbone. He (I guess?) reflects back on the time he first came to King’s Landing and sought out the remains of the dragons. King Robert had banished the skeletons to a cellar but Tyrion found them and was amazed by them. There were 19 of them, the largest being Balerion, large enough to swallow aurochs whole, the smallest being the size of Mastiff skulls.

 

We also get a little Lannister / Westeros history. I’m not certain if it’s relevant or just more world building. King Loren of the Rock & King Mern of the Reach (when the Seven Kingdoms were kingdoms and not provinces) joined to try and fight Aegon Dragonlord. They lost, despite having more numbers. King Loren lived, pledged fealty to the Targaryens, and beget a son.

 

Jon Snow asks Tyrion why Tyrion reads so much. Jon Snow is not what we would call an academic. This won’t be the last time he questions why people read. Tyrion, however, decides to answer him honestly and asks Jon to “Look at me and tell me what you see.” Jon, of course is suspicious and polite, and answers with Tyrion’s name. Tyrion points out that he, Tyrion, is a dwarf. Tyrion points out the many problems he has with being a dwarf, from needing special equipment to ride a horse, to his arms being too short to make a swordsman. He also points out that his father was Hand to the King that his brother killed. He ends this monologue by saying that his mind is his weapon.

 

They talk for a bit. Tyrion thinks that Jon has the Stark face, and that whomever Jon’s mother is, she left little of herself in her son. (L+R=J) To further the L+R=J speculation, the conversation drifts toward dragons. Jon points out there are no more dragons. Tyrion talks about how he dreamed of riding a dragon and watching his sister and father burn.

 

Jon looks horrified at this, and Tyrian questions him, prodding into Jon’s insecurities about Lady Stark, Robb, Winterfell, and the Wall. Jon gets upset and is close to tears. Tyrion feels guilty and goes to pat him on the shoulder when Ghost attacks Tyrion.

 

Jon forces him to ask nicely, and when Tyrion does, Jon calls of the wolf. They return to camp.

 

Characters Mentioned:                 

  • Robert Baratheon
  • Eddard Stark
  • Aegon Targaryen: Unleashed dragons on the Seven Kingdoms of Old.
  • Balerion, Meraxes, Vhaghar: Targaryen dragons
  • King Loren of the Rock: Lannister ancestor.
  • King Mern of the Reach: Joined Lannister ancestors to oppose Targaryen conquest.

     

 

Other Locations Mentioned:

  • Winterfell
  • King’s Landing
  • Summer Isles
  • Casterly Rock – Where the Lannisters come from.
  • Port of Ibben – hairy mammoths said to roam the cold wastes here.

     

 

Thoughts:

  • This is another chapter where the majority of the “action” is just a dialogue between two people. I’m beginning to see GRRM’s television roots in this book.
  • I enjoyed the bit of Westeros history this time around. I don’t think I ever noticed it before.
  • Another “shout-out” to Jon’s very Stark-like appearance.
  • I like the interaction between Jon & Tyrion. Tyrion wasn’t too upset at the humiliation and before he was attacked he was on the verge of apology.
  • Jon really isn’t into the reading, and he’s got a bit of a temper.
  • I don’t know if Tyrion will ride a dragon. But I do know that this passage about Tyrion and dragons is cited a lot when people talk about Tyrion being a dragon rider. I do wonder if this dreaming of fires and dragons is just normal Westeros boy stuff, or if it has something to do with the stuff about Aerys and Johanna in TWOIAF.
  • I wonder who those two raper boys from the fingers that Yoren is bringing to the Wall are.
  • Jon is showing signs of maturity by the end. “It is what it is.” Poor Jon.
  • Will Tyrion lose his intelligence? He lists people’s strengths, and the people he listed have lost their strength. Robert’s Warhammer won’t do him any good. Jaime loses his sword hand.   Or just coincidence?
  • What is the point of “conquering?” Burning people alive with dragons for what?
  • For some reason, I was surprised that Jon shared a tent with Benjen. And Benjen was kind of Uncle-ly toward Jon in their interactions. 

 

Links to Previous Chapter Recaps: 

  • Upvote 1

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

clueliss

Posted

Bit of foreshadowing there with the dragon stuff (in general).

and I really love Tyrion.  (and Jon) but in this case, Tyrion.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

I love Tyrion, but he's not without fault. Same with Jon. Actually, all the characters in ASOIAF are flawed. Some more deeply than others. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
clueliss

Posted

That might be why I like them.  They aren't "Mary Sue's."  They have flaws and lose their tempers and do stupid things.  

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

12 minutes ago, clueliss said:

That might be why I like them.  They aren't "Mary Sue's."  They have flaws and lose their tempers and do stupid things.  

Someone once tried to tell me Arya was a Mary Sue. Yeah. Because the 10 year old assassin isn't flawed at all. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
clueliss

Posted

oh geez.  Nope.  Not a Mary Sue.  She goes off and does lots of stupid things.  She is flawed.  She's wandering around with a death list she puts herself to sleep with.    I could argue that Sansa's close to Mary Sue that Arya if I had to (at least at first).  Also Cersei is Mary Sue crossed with Snidley Whiplash if you ask me.  The Tyrell chick is rather Mary Sue.  But Arya?  Nope.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

I think Cersei is a mary sue in the show because every flaw she has (the drinking, the desperate need for control ect) is flipped around and made into a poor Cersei situation. Like, 'poor Cersei, she's being driven to wine because everyone around her is awful!' and 'poor Cersei, she's as desperate to control Tommen as Margaery is, but that's only because she's a mother lioness protecting her cubs!'. Hell, they even reversed her role with Jaime in the show so he's the one wanting to continue Tywin's legacy and she's the one who wants to run off and just be a family together.

I hate how they whitewash Cersei and Tyrion in the show. They're flawed characters to say the least, and should be presented as such.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
clueliss

Posted

By the way, when i reference Snidley Whiplash (cartoon character from my childhood) I'm talking about 'mustache twirling' or what I'll call cliched villain behavior.  

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

I'm wondering if it is going to come out that Tyrion is not Tywin's biological son.  Dragon riders have to be Targareans.  At this point 2 of the dragon riders are pretty much established, it is the identity of #3 that is a complete mystery.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

3 minutes ago, AreteJo said:

I'm wondering if it is going to come out that Tyrion is not Tywin's biological son.  Dragon riders have to be Targareans.  At this point 2 of the dragon riders are pretty much established, it is the identity of #3 that is a complete mystery.

My sort of ridiculous guess is that he is a chimera. He's got two different colored eyes. He's OBVIOUSLY Tywin's son. But the World of Ice and Fire alludes to Aerys taking first night privilege with Joanna. Then again, TWOIAF is also written by an unreliable, biased, narrator. 

I do and I don't want Tyrion to be a hidden Targ. I think we sort of have to many secret Targs running around. Also, his arc about how much he is like Tywin would be pointless instead of bittersweet. 

Link to comment

I actually really like your idea of Tyrion being a chimera- that would be a cool way of giving him dragon's blood without severing the relationship to Tywin and the depth that relationship gives to Tyrion's character and actions.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • RulerOfTheQueensNavy

      Posted (edited)

      On 3/13/2024 at 11:57 AM, hoipolloi said:

      An excellent commentary on the rotting corpse of the SBC and those who are protecting it:

      They are doing a series on Pressler over at The Wartburg Watch.  Nothing really new there, but a pretty good summary if you're not caught up.  

      What a lot of people including Wartburg seem to be missing is that Paul Pressler caring what the SBC believed is just a smokescreen.  The reality is this, the SBC is the single largest evangelical voting block in the country.  The lay people involved in the SBC from the Council of National Policy (like Paul Pressler, or Rod Martin) will do whatever it takes to keep this block voting Republican.  They need to cover up abuse in church, not for the sake of the church, but because it could breakup a huge block that can be controlled right now.

      Edited by RulerOfTheQueensNavy
      Wanted to add thoughts.
    • SassyPants

      Posted

      I would think having already experienced a uterine rupture, and IIRC this was with Freddy and about 3 weeks before his due date, Jill is in a higher than average risk for untoward events and likely is on a very individualized OBGYN plan. Navigating a pregnancy and safe birth after having had a previous uterine rupture and never having had a vaginal delivery has to make Jill’s care quite unique. I hope she utilizes high risk maternal/fetal practitioners. 

    • Giraffe

      Posted

      1 minute ago, JermajestyDuggar said:

      You weren’t ready for college….. that’s why you dropped out.

      You weren’t ready for that new job…. So you were fired.

      You weren’t ready to potty train… so you gave up after a week.

      You weren’t ready to homeschool….. so your kids fell behind.

      You weren’t ready to buy that house…. So you were denied a loan. 
       

      Does she not realize that when you aren’t ready, things can fail spectacularly? I try very hard not to place expectations on my kids that they can’t handle. They aren’t ready for algebra. So I’m not going to force them to learn it. Her thinking is completely flawed. 

      Exactly! There are way more instances where "no, you're not actually ready" is the appropriate response. 

      • Upvote 1
    • JermajestyDuggar

      Posted

      You weren’t ready for college….. that’s why you dropped out.

      You weren’t ready for that new job…. So you were fired.

      You weren’t ready to potty train… so you gave up after a week.

      You weren’t ready to homeschool….. so your kids fell behind.

      You weren’t ready to buy that house…. So you were denied a loan. 
       

      Does she not realize that when you aren’t ready, things can fail spectacularly? I try very hard not to place expectations on my kids that they can’t handle. They aren’t ready for algebra. So I’m not going to force them to learn it. Her thinking is completely flawed. 

      • Upvote 1
      • I Agree 1
    • Giraffe

      Posted

      Here's the thing. "You're never going to be ready so you might as well do it now" can actually be good advice - in very specific situations! But overall as a general post for your broader audience? That's horrible advice! It's also profoundly tone deaf and painfully unaware of her own immense privilege. It's easy to have kids & to start your own business from scratch when "from scratch" is having access to hundreds of thousands of dollars! 

      • I Agree 1


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.