Jump to content

Flowers in the Attic: "Holidays" Part 2


Maggie Mae

2,052 views

Holidays: Part 2 (Page 176) 

I forgot to mention a very crucial plot point yesterday. Cathy asks for bananas and Mother refuses because her father doesn't care for them. Yup. Was there no editor at whatever publishing firm took on this mess? 

It is now Christmas Eve and the children have been "living" at Foxworth Hall for 5 months. They still have not seen the entire house. To be fair, I'm certain that the staff hasn't seen the entire house, either. They are still saying grace before every meal, praying before bed, keeping their thoughts pure and innocent (except, you know, when they knowingly disobey the grandmother by sunbathing nude on some old mattresses and inspecting each other genitals.) Cathy believes that the meals they are provided are growing poorer in quality by the day. She doesn't actually address how they are not as great as before. We get pages of details about gifts and the mothers "filmy negligee" but for something like "how are the meals not good anymore" we get "they grow poorer and poorer by the day." Are they less substantial? Are they getting rotten fruit? Do they have to eat gruel and cold mush? 

It doesn't matter because Cathy is upset about not being able to go Christmas Shopping. But she consoles herself by reminding herself that in the future she'll be rich, rich, rich! And then she'll be able to go into a store and buy anything she wants! (Except, you know what, Cathy? The high end stores will realize that their guests have unlimited money and start making ridiculous things like pre-mudded jeans, and you'll buy them and then the poors like me will laugh at you.) 

Chris and Cathy have been making secret gifts for Momma and the twins. She's also secretly knitting a cap for Chris in the bathroom. Chris decides they need to make the grandmother a gift as well. Where are they getting the supplies for secret gifts? Our narrator describes the gift but doesn't actually say what it is, so I don't really know. Something about linen and a "stretcher frame" and me being uncrafty, I have no idea what they are doing. 

Mother brings them a tree. Okay, so now I'm supposed to believe that she's sneaking in a tree and the staff doesn't notice, yet she can't smuggle out a 4 year old for a trip to the hospital? 

They are given false promises of forgetting the time in the attic once they are in their own house in the future. 

The mother sneaks into the room in the middle of the night to fill stockings and put gifts under the tree. They are given candy, and nuts, and fruit, and gum, and chocolate. Which, IIRC, the grandmother said NO CANDY EVER. 

Carrie wants to know how Santa found them, which is, for once, an age appropriate question. 

Cathy points out that Chris's movements remind her of her father (whom she was clearly in love with, making me question VC Andrew's relationship with her own parents) and cries a bit. Then she looks around some more, and cries because she believes that her mom is trying and cares and loves them. Ah, because gifts = love. She's ashamed for thinking mean thoughts. Chris tells her to get up. Shut up, Chris. 

Santa's note told them to hide the candy from the grandmother. BUT WHAT ABOUT THE WRAPPERS? That's how you get ants! 

Cathy sits on the floor wearing a "stunning new robe of green velvet." They all got new robes. Did any of you get excited about new robes and pajamas when you were ... ever? I mean, I'd be happy for a new robe for Christmas, but excited? And to call a robe "stunning?" 

The grandmother comes in. They finally tell us that the gift is a painting which they created a garden. 3D collage style, from materials found in the attic. I wonder what they destroyed to make silk butterflies. 

Grandmother doesn't take the gift. Shocking. A lot of talk about the grandmother's cold eyes, her stone cold eyes. Grandmother's scornful eyes. 

Cathy is hurt and flings it to the ground, and swears and stomps on it. Chris tries to save it and they decide that they tried and Grandmother doesn't try. 

*** 

It's still christmas. Momma comes up to the room next to the attic, and gives them a dollhouse. Well, she gives Cory and Carrie a dollhouse. And the description - Corrine's dialogue - is marvelous. 

Quote

 

"It is very valuable, too," she gushed. "On the right market, a dollhouse like this would bring a fabulous fortune. Just the miniature porcelain dolls with the moveable joints alone are priceless, their faces all hand-painted. The dolls are made to scale to the house, as is the furniture, the paintings - everything, in fact. The house was handcrafted by an artist who lived in England. Each chair, table, bed, lamp, chandelier -- all are genuine reproductions of antiques. I understand it took the craftsman twelve years to complete this.

"Look at how the little doors open and close, perfectly hung -- which is more than you can say for the house you are living in," she went on. "And all the drawers slide in and out. There's a tiny little key to lock the desk, and look how some of the doors slide into the walls -- pocket doors, they are called. I wish this house had doors like that; I don't know why they went out of fashion. And see the hand-carved moldings near the ceiling, and the wainscoting in the dining room and library - and the teensy books on the shelves. Believe it or not, if you have a microscope, you can read the text!" 

 

I'll let you make your own jokes about 5 year olds and their interest in wainscoting. 

Christopher takes a book and tries to read it, squinting and holding it close. Cathy mentions that there is "a special kind of microscope he hopes to own someday." And how she "hopes to be the one to give it to him." Is it a special microscope so he can see his penis? 

It just keeps going on and on about the stupid dollhouse. I don't care. 

Mother says that it used to belong to her mother (I think that's the grandmother?) It was in a glass display case (which they call a glass box.) Finally, her father smashed the "glass box" and let Corrine play with it, as long as she doesn't break anything. Spoilers: she broke something. She was whipped for breaking a boy doll after she tried to take its clothes off. 

Carrie likes the dollhouse and Cory is interested in it because Carrie is. 

They are given tricycles and roller skates. WTF. 

Oh, and a TV! But no DVD player. How is Comcast going to install their cable service without anyone knowing? Hope they can get a good antenna signal in the attic. Also, imagine all the quality daytime tv they get to watch now! Days of Our Lives, Maury Povich and his paternity testing, Price is Right, Jenny Jones, The People's Court, General Hospital... They are going to learn so much! Oh and maybe Sesame Street, this predates the HBO thing. 

Mother also tells them that her father is having her put back in the will!  Because if there is one thing that 12 year old girls care about, it's contract law! 

And then Mother tells them that there will be a party that night to reintroduce her to society. Ugh. What kind of weird-ass grownup debutante ball will this be? Oh, it's going to be a  "grand affair." Lovely. I'm sure your children look forward to you telling them about it. At least they don't have to perform, ala Sound of Music. 

How the hell did she get the dollhouse upstairs without anyone noticing? Doesn't the staff wonder why she's always hiding in the attic?  I guess she could be putting it into long term storage, but what about the potted tree? Or the TV? TVs used to be a lot heavier. 

 

 

  • Upvote 7

11 Comments


Recommended Comments

GreyhoundFan

Posted

Quote

How the hell did she get the dollhouse upstairs without anyone noticing? Doesn't the staff wonder why she's always hiding in the attic?  I guess she could be putting it into long term storage, but what about the potted tree? Or the TV? TVs used to be a lot heavier. 

I wondered that as well. The way she described the dollhouse, it must have been made of wood and is huge. So, did she find a hand-truck to move it?  And, as far as the staff thinking she's putting stuff into storage, I would think that they knew that Corinne wouldn't break a nail lifting her own fork, much less lifting heavy items and moving them around the house. When I read the books in my youth, I didn't catch all the plot holes so large you could drive a tractor-trailer through them.

 

BTW, great recaps!

  • Upvote 10
Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

Spoiler alert (for those who haven't read the book)... Toward the end, when Chris and Cathy start sneaking around the house and stealing to fund their escape, I always thought they were stupid for not realizing they had a whole attic full of priceless (and presumably at least some small, portable) antiques, not to mention the dollhouse and all the priceless collectables inside it. I was twelve when I read this book, and I even thought about it back then, especially when I read that chapter where Chris went on that last raid and found all his mom's valuables were gone. In the next book, it turns out that Cathy did steal some of the dolls, but she did it for Carrie, not because she intended to hock them.

  • Upvote 8
Link to comment
Destiny

Posted

LOL! A+ Archer reference. DO YOU WANT ANTS?

I am enjoying these recaps. The books were a nightmare, but your recaps are fun. <3

  • Upvote 4
Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

Oh, and a TV! But no DVD player. How is Comcast going to install their cable service without anyone knowing? Hope they can get a good antenna signal in the attic. Also, imagine all the quality daytime tv they get to watch now! Days of Our Lives, Maury Povich and his paternity testing, Price is Right, Jenny Jones, The People's Court, General Hospital... They are going to learn so much! Oh and maybe Sesame Street, this predates the HBO thing.

Some of those shows existed when the book was written, but not at the time it takes place (IIRC, 1957 to 1960). So we're talking about squeaky clean family friendly TV here-- "Father Knows Best", "Ozzie and Harriet", "Leave It To Beaver." Oh, and the original "Mickey Mouse Club." It must have blown the twins' minds to compare the kids on TV with their own horrible existence, but V.C. Andrews didn't go there. (Emma Donoghue did go there in "Room." But little Jack was raised to believe that the world outside of TV was not real; he doesn't learn the truth until later.)

  • Upvote 8
Link to comment
JordynDarby5

Posted

I love how Corinne was allowed to drag a tree and huge dollhouse though the house and no one found it odd. That dollhouse sounded incredible. 

  • Upvote 7
Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

Well, we can be pretty sure the grandmother didn't help Corrine with any heavy lifting, although it sounds like she was capable of it!

Maybe Corrine used some kind of wheely cart? Maybe she moved the stuff around the house at night when the servants were off-duty and stored it all in one of the nearby bedrooms that no one ever used? For all we know, the dollhouse could have already been stored in one of those rooms.

  • Upvote 3
Link to comment
HerNameIsBuffy

Posted

On 9/21/2017 at 12:10 AM, FloraDoraDolly said:

Spoiler alert (for those who haven't read the book)... Toward the end, when Chris and Cathy start sneaking around the house and stealing to fund their escape, I always thought they were stupid for not realizing they had a whole attic full of priceless (and presumably at least some small, portable) antiques, not to mention the dollhouse and all the priceless collectables inside it. I was twelve when I read this book, and I even thought about it back then, especially when I read that chapter where Chris went on that last raid and found all his mom's valuables were gone. In the next book, it turns out that Cathy did steal some of the dolls, but she did it for Carrie, not because she intended to hock them.

Pre-google I can't imagine they'd have any way to know how to sell it.  You can't give an antique to the driver for bus fare.  

I went a different way...I never understood why they didn't take advantage of all those people there to scream.  Once a room full of people know you exist gossip will help protect your lives.

I blame Chris.

  • Upvote 3
Link to comment
clueliss

Posted

The TV reception bit did not bother me back in the day - because honestly, it was 1980something before we had cable.  (and we got cable because of the iffy tv reception we got where my mother and stepfather lived.  So at the time I read that - we had rabbit ears antenna and they probably got better reception in the attic than the rest of the house.  

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
HerNameIsBuffy

Posted

15 minutes ago, clueliss said:

The TV reception bit did not bother me back in the day - because honestly, it was 1980something before we had cable.  (and we got cable because of the iffy tv reception we got where my mother and stepfather lived.  So at the time I read that - we had rabbit ears antenna and they probably got better reception in the attic than the rest of the house.  

Agree about the reception being better up there.  Thinking of logistics, Maggie mentioned how much larger/heavier tvs were back then and she's right.  If they could smuggle a tv they could smuggle a little fridge.  They had small ones, hardly bigger than the minis for dorm rooms.  Because I'm with MM for being afraid of refrigerated potato salad.  

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Maggie Mae

Posted

13 hours ago, HerNameIsBuffy said:

Pre-google I can't imagine they'd have any way to know how to sell it.  You can't give an antique to the driver for bus fare.  

And while some of us knew all about pawn shops as kids, I can imagine that Corrine would find that distasteful and her kids wouldn't know anything about that. 

13 hours ago, HerNameIsBuffy said:

I went a different way...I never understood why they didn't take advantage of all those people there to scream.  Once a room full of people know you exist gossip will help protect your lives.

These are not worldly children. 

13 hours ago, HerNameIsBuffy said:

I blame Chris.

It's usually his fault. 

  • Upvote 3
Link to comment
FloraDoraDolly

Posted

13 hours ago, Maggie Mae said:

And while some of us knew all about pawn shops as kids, I can imagine that Corrine would find that distasteful and her kids wouldn't know anything about that.

But Chris did steal his mother's wedding ring-- it was the only small item of value that he could find-- so he must have had some idea that pawn shops existed. Maybe he saw something about it on TV or read it in a book?

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Posts

    • Ozlsn

      Posted

      3 hours ago, Xan said:

      She could have actually had the kitchen designed so it would be easier to prep for meals and clean up afterwards.  I see nothing like that

      I don't think her mind goes to functionality because she's not using that space for much. She's all pretty! Shiny!! NEW!!

      3 hours ago, Xan said:

      She mentioned in a story yesterday that she had to clean some poopy diapers so the boys are nearly four and she still isn't toilet training them.  They will stay babies for a couple more years

      I would be getting that looked into (ie seeing a continence nurse), that's unusually late to be still in diapers, particularly with older siblings. If she can't see that that is a problem it's a bit of a worry.

    • MomKB

      Posted

      Ugh, she is constantly reminding everyone that they built the house themselves. 🙄

    • Mama Mia

      Posted (edited)

      2 hours ago, justmy2cents said:

      I think Joy is one of the siblings that was critical of Jill when she pulled away from the family the way she did, and they may not have much of a relationship right now. Don’t see any interaction on social media, though I know we don’t see everything. That would be a shame if that was the case, especially since Jill was there for Joy when Joy lost Annabelle. 

      Joy commented on the IG post. Saying she was heartbroken for them or similar. She comments occasionally, the usual “ how cute” about a kid pic or whatever.  All the married daughters seem supportive of each other.  I don’t think we can really judge off social media interaction, or even photos together. They are all busy, with lots of small children, and most of the events we get photos of are crowded with not everyone present necessarily in the picture. They may text or send each other funny memes or get together for coffee and we know nothing about it. 

      Edited by Mama Mia
      • Upvote 1
    • anachronistic

      Posted

      In Chelsea's Easter pictures George is wearing an outfit that I literally have never seen ever. It almost looks like weird plus fours. She is slowly inching him into pants I guess. Is Pentecostal fashion very big and blousy like what the older girls wear? It looks like the shape would be comfortable but the fabrics wouldn't be. I guess if you are aiming for a potato sack shape you need to add as much lace and ruffles and florals as possible to make sure that people know it is clothing. 

    • Giraffe

      Posted

      10 minutes ago, JermajestyDuggar said:

      If the kids all get a bath before bed and then put on their clothes for the next day, it’s not too gross. But I always had bed wetters so changing everything in the morning was a non negotiable. But if her kids don’t wet the bed, then I guess it’s not a huge deal.

      There's no way her kids are magically not bed wetters. They've probably just learned she doesn't give a shit so they grab an older sibling or their grandmother for help. No doubt Braggie has no clue what's going on with her kids over the course of a day. She's an aggressively incompetent parent. 

      Braggie strikes me as the type of parent who has this idea in her head of what her children do over the course of the day while her older children and her mother would be standing there wondering what strangers she's talking about. 



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.